safe inspect and adapt problem solving workshop

We are back in Europe and hope you join us!

Prague, Czech Republic, 15 – 17, May 2023

Evolving the Scaled Agile Framework:

Update to SAFe 5

Guidance for organizing around value, DevSecOps, and agility for business teams

• SAFe Contributors
• Extended SAFe Guidance
• Community Contributions
• SAFe Beyond IT
• Books on SAFe
• Download SAFe Posters & Graphics
• Presentations & Videos
• FAQs on how to use SAFe content and trademarks
• What’s new in the SAFe 5.1 Big Picture
• Recommended Reading
• Learn about the Community
• Member Login
• SAFe Implementation Roadmap
• Find a Transformation Partner
• Find a Platform Partner
• Customer Stories
• SAFe Training

Kaizen is about changing the way things are. If you assume that things are all right the way they are, you can’t do kaizen. So change something! —Taiichi Ohno

Inspect and Adapt

Inspect & adapt: overview.

The Agile Manifesto emphasizes the importance of continuous improvement through the following principle: “At regular intervals, the team reflects on how to become more effective, then tunes and adjusts its behavior accordingly.”

In addition, SAFe includes ‘relentless improvement’ as one of the four pillars of the SAFe House of Lean as well as a dimension of the Continuous Learning Culture core competency. While opportunities to improve can and should occur continuously throughout the Program Increment (PI) (e.g., Iteration Retrospectives ), applying some structure, cadence, and synchronization helps ensure that there is also time set aside to identify improvements across multiple teams and Agile Release Trains.

All ART stakeholders participate along with the Agile Teams in the I&A event. The result is a set of improvement backlog items that go into the Program Backlog for the next PI Planning event. In this way, every Agile Release Train (ART) improves every PI. For large solutions , a similar I&A event is held by the Solution Train .

The I&A event consists of three parts:

PI System Demo

• Quantitative and qualitative measurement
• Retrospective and problem-solving workshop

Participants in the I&A should be, wherever possible, all the people involved in building the solution. These include for an ART:

• The Agile teams
• Release Train Engineer (RTE)
• System and Solution Architects/Engineering
• Product Management ,  Business Owners , and others on the train

Additionally, Solution Train stakeholders may attend this event.

The PI System Demo is the first part of the I&A, and it’s a little different from the regular system demos that happen after every iteration, in that it is intended to show all the Features that the ART has developed over the course of the PI. Typically the audience is broader, for example, customers or Portfolio representatives are more likely to attend this demo. Therefore, the PI system demo tends to be a little more formal, and some extra preparation and staging are usually required. But like any other system demo, it should be timeboxed to an hour or less, with the level of abstraction high enough to keep stakeholders actively engaged and providing feedback.

Prior to, or as part of the PI system demo, Business Owners collaborate with each Agile team to score the actual business value achieved for each of their Team PI Objectives .

Quantitative and Qualitative Measurement

In the second part of the I&A event, teams collectively review any quantitative and qualitative metrics they have agreed to collect, then discuss the data and trends. In preparation for this, the RTE and the Solution Train Engineer are often responsible for gathering the information, analyzing it to identify potential issues, and facilitating the presentation of the findings to the ART.

One primary metric is the program predictability measure. Each team’s planned vs. actual business value is rolled up to create the program predictability measure, as shown in Figure 2.

Reliable trains should operate in the 80–100 percent range; this allows the business and its external stakeholders to plan effectively. (Note: Uncommitted objectives don’t count toward the commitment but do count toward the actual business value achievement, as can also be seen in Figure 1.)

Retrospective

The teams then run a brief (30 minutes or less) retrospective, the goal of which is to identify a few significant issues they would like to address during the problem-solving workshop . There is no one way to do this; several different Agile retrospective formats can be used [3].

Based on the retrospective, and the nature of the problems identified, the facilitator helps the group decide which issues they want to tackle. Each team may work on a problem, or, more typically, new groups are formed from individuals across different teams who wish to work on the same issue. This self-selection helps provide cross-functional and differing views of the problem, and it brings together those who are impacted and those who are best motivated to address the issue.

Key ART stakeholders—including Business Owners, customers, and management—join the teams in the retrospective and problem-solving workshop. Often it is the Business Owners alone who can unblock the impediments that exist outside the team’s control.

Problem-Solving Workshop

For addressing systemic problems, a structured, root-cause problem-solving workshop is held by the ART. Root cause analysis provides a set of problem-solving tools used to identify the actual causes of a problem, rather than just addressing the symptoms. The session is typically facilitated by the RTE, in a timebox of two hours or less.

Figure 3 illustrates the steps in the problem-solving workshop.

The following sections describe each step of the process.

Agree on the Problem(s) to Solve

American inventor Charles Kettering is credited with the statement that “a problem well stated is a problem half solved.” At this point, the teams have self-selected the problem they want to address. But, do they agree on the details of the problem, or is it more likely that they have differing perspectives? To this end, the teams should spend a few minutes clearly stating the problem, highlighting the ‘what’, ‘where’, ‘when’, and ‘impact’ as succinctly as they can. Figure 4 illustrates a well-written problem statement.

Perform Root Cause Analysis

Effective problem-solving tools include the fishbone diagram and the ‘5 Whys.’ Also known as an Ishikawa Diagram , a fishbone diagram is a visual tool used to explore the causes of specific events or sources of variation in a process. Figure 5 illustrates the fishbone diagram with a summary of the previous problem statement written at the head of the ‘fish.’

For our problem-solving workshop, we preload the main bones with the categories people, process, tools, program, and environment. However, these may be adapted as appropriate.

Team members then brainstorm causes that they think contribute to the problem to be solved and group them into these categories. Once a cause is identified, its root cause is explored with the 5 Whys technique. By simply asking ‘why’ multiple times, the cause of the previous cause is uncovered, and added to the diagram. The process stops once a suitable root cause has been identified and the same process is then applied to the next cause.

Identify the Biggest Root Cause

Pareto Analysis , also known as the 80/20 rule, is a technique used to narrow down the number of actions that produce the most significant overall effect. It uses the principle that 20 percent of the causes are responsible for 80 percent of the problem. It’s especially useful when many possible courses of action are competing for attention, which is almost always the case with complex, systemic issues.

Once all the possible causes-of-causes have been identified, team members then cumulatively vote on the item they think is the most significant factor contributing to the original problem. They can do this by dot voting (five votes are allocated to each person, which can be spread among one or more items as they see fit) on the causes they think are most problematic. The team then summarizes the votes in a Pareto chart, such as the example in Figure 6, which illustrates their collective consensus on the most significant root cause.

Restate the New Problem

The next step is to pick the cause with the most votes and restate it clearly as a problem. This should take only a few minutes or so, as the teams have a good understanding of this root cause by now.

Brainstorm Solutions

At this point, the restated problem will start to imply some potential solutions. The team brainstorms as many possible corrective actions as they can think of within a fixed timebox (about 15–30 minutes). The rules of brainstorming apply here:

• Generate as many ideas as possible
• Do not allow criticism or debate
• Let the imagination soar
• Explore and combine ideas

Create Improvement Backlog Items

The team then cumulatively votes on up to three most likely solutions. These are rephrased as improvement stories and features to be fed directly into the PI Planning event that follows. During that event, the RTE helps ensure that the relevant work needed to deliver the identified improvements is planned. This closes the loop, thus ensuring that action will be taken and that people and resources are dedicated as necessary to improve the current state.

In this way, problem-solving becomes routine and systematic, and team members and ART stakeholders can be assured that the train is solidly on its journey of relentless improvement.

Inspect and Adapt at the Large Solution Level

The above describes a rigorous approach to problem-solving in the context of a single ART. If the ART is part of a Solution Train the I&A event will often include key stakeholders from the Large Solution level. In larger value streams, however, an additional large solution level I&A event may be required, following the same format.

Due to the number of people in a Solution Train, attendees at the large solution I&A event cannot include everyone, so stakeholders are selected that are best suited to address the problems faced. This includes the primary stakeholders of the Solution Train, as well as representatives from the various ARTs and Suppliers .

Last update: 10 February 2021

Privacy Overview

Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.

Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.

• +44 (0)20 8145 5000
• [email protected]
• 63/66 Hatton Garden, Fifth Floor Suite 23, London, EC1N 8LE

• Agile HR Course
• Lean Agile Centre of Excellence
• Agile Coaching

Which activity happens in the Inspect and Adapt workshop?

Pick one of 4 options:.

A) A retrospective of the iteration B) Planning the next PI C) A demo of the integrated system D) Refreshing the Program Backlog

Scroll to the bottom to find out! But first, learn more below…

Inspect and Adapt

In SAFe, the Inspect and Adapt (I&A) Workshop is a regularly scheduled event that is held at the end of each Program Increment (PI). The purpose of the I&A Workshop is to review the progress made during the PI, identify any improvements that can be made to the process, and make adjustments as needed to ensure that the organization is able to continue delivering value to the customer on a regular basis.

As part of the review process, participants also assess the effectiveness of the practices and processes that were used during the PI and identify any areas where improvements can be made. This may involve evaluating the use of Scrum, Lean, and other Agile practices, as well as the effectiveness of the technical infrastructure and tools that were used.

Once the review is complete, participants work together to identify any improvements that can be made to the process. This may involve making adjustments to the way that work is organized and prioritized, improving the way that teams collaborate and communicate, or introducing new tools or practices that will help the organization to be more effective.

The I&A Workshop is an important part of the SAFe framework, as it provides a regular opportunity for the organization to review its progress and make adjustments as needed to ensure that it is able to continue delivering value to the customer. By regularly reviewing and adapting its practices, the organization can continuously improve its ability to deliver value and respond to the changing needs of the customer.

Who Participates?

Ideally, everybody involved in building the solution. In the context of the ART, this includes the agile teams, the RTE, system and solution architects, etc. All are welcome to help identify backlog items.

And now for the answer…

C) A demo of the integrated system!

Go into more depth on the Scaled Agile Framework and its various events on a SAFe- certified course . Or, learn more about the Inspect & Adapt workshop specifically and download an overview here .

Connect with Value Glide!

 Are you looking to adopt Agile ways of working? If so, SAFe, Scrum and Kanban could be the perfect solution for you. For expert guidance to successfully adopt and implement SAFem Scrum or Kanban, Value Glide is here to help. Our team has the skills and experience to ensure your Agile adoption is seamless and successful.

Connect with us for Agile Training, Agile Consulting, and Agile coaching.

• SAFe Training
• SAFe Consulting
• SAFe Quickstart ART Launch
• Value Stream Mapping Workshops
• Scrum Training
• Kanban Training

Visit https://www.valueglide.com for more information.

You may also like...

What is the role of the Lean-Agile Center of Excellence in SAFe?

What would be a great outcome from a SAFe coaching engagement?

What is the final element of the continuous delivery pipeline?

Kanbaning your Scrum (3 of 3)

You might remember my posts on “Professional Scrum with Kanban – Don’t just limit WIP – optimise it! (posts 1 of 3 and 2 of 3)”. I used

SAFe Principle 6: Visualise and limit WIP, reduce batch sizes, and manage queued lengths.

Most Valuable Contribution of a SAFe Consultant

Latest Blog Posts

What does Agile HR look, sound and feel like in practice?

Case Studies in Agile HR: How Leading Organizations Align HR with Agile Values As the business world continues to embrace Agile methodologies, many organizations are

how does the agile hr course align with agile principles and frameworks, and how does that help hr departments?

Embrace Agility with the Agile HR Course: Transforming HR for the Future As organizations embark on their Agile and digital transformation journeys, the role of

Why is the Agile HR course relevant?

Why the Agile HR Course is Essential for HR Professionals In a world where change is the only constant, HR professionals are increasingly finding themselves

Transforming Vision into Velocity : Elevate Your Agile Journey with Value Glide’s Expert SAFe Consulting, Coaching, and Training.

Useful Links

Connect with us.

Connect with us on social media and stay up to date with our latest offers, news, and mastering SAFe series.

©2024. Value Glide. All Rights Reserved.

Website created & supported by FireWerks Marketing + Design

Click one of our contacts below to chat on WhatsApp

Social Chat is free, download and try it now here!

• Practice Exam

Navigating the Inspect & Adapt Workshop: The Key to Continuous Improvement in SAFe

0  Comments

In the dynamic world of Agile, the Inspect & Adapt Workshop stands as a cornerstone in the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe). It’s a pivotal moment where Agile teams converge to reflect, learn, and plan for the future. But what exactly are the outcomes of this workshop? Today, let’s delve into the heart of this process and understand why “Identifying and prioritizing process improvements” is not just an option, but the primary outcome of the Inspect & Adapt Workshop.

The Essence of the Inspect & Adapt Workshop

At its core, the Inspect & Adapt (I&A) Workshop is a structured problem-solving session. It marks the end of the Program Increment (PI) and serves as a critical reflection point. Teams gather to inspect their achievements and adapt their processes, learning from their experiences. It’s not just about what we did, but how we did it and how we can do it better.

Why Process Improvement is Key

Among the options provided – creation of user stories, release of the product to customers, and setting the agenda for the next PI – identifying and prioritizing process improvements stands out. Why? Because continuous improvement is the lifeblood of Agile. While releasing products and creating user stories are essential, they are part of the ongoing Agile process. The I&A Workshop’s unique contribution is its focus on elevating the process itself.

Real-Life Application

Imagine a team working on a software development project. They’ve had a successful PI, with several user stories completed and features shipped. However, during the I&A Workshop, they realize that certain bottlenecks in communication slowed them down. By identifying and addressing these issues, the team sets the stage for more efficient sprints in the future, ultimately leading to better products and happier customers.

The Inspect & Adapt Workshop is more than a routine meeting; it’s an opportunity for genuine growth. By focusing on process improvements, SAFe practitioners ensure that their Agile journey is not static but a path of continuous evolution and enhancement

You may also like

The three skills of an effective safe scrum master: communication, coordination, cooperation, building trust in planning: the team’s commitment in safe, get in touch.

Session expired

Please log in again. The login page will open in a new tab. After logging in you can close it and return to this page.

• Skip to content

Problem-solving workshop: Step-by-Step

A problem-solving workshop is held by the Agile Release Train and its purpose is to address systematic problems. The workshop that concentrates on identifying the problems, not just addressing the symptoms, is facilitated by the Release Train Engineer and time-boxed to maximum of two hours. What are the six steps of the workshop?

In SAFe® (Scaled Agile Framework for Enterprises®), problem-solving workshop is done during the Inspect & Adapt (I & A) event. I & A  is held at the end of each Program Increment, and it forms the basis for relentless improvement, one of the four pillars of the SAFe House of Lean , and a dimension of the Continuous Learning Culture core competency.

During the three parts of I & A event (PI System Demo, Quantitative and Qualitative measurement, and Retrospective and problem-solving workshop), the ART demonstrates and evaluates the current state of the solution and teams reflect and identify improvement backlog items. In this article we are going to concentrate on the last part of the event, problem-solving workshop, during which teams systematically address the larger impediments that are limiting velocity.

Problem-solving workshop consists of 6 steps

Step 1: agree on the problem to solve.

Clearly stating the problem is key to problem identification and correction. It enables more focused investigation, time-saving, and avoids ‘ready, fire, aim’ approach. On the other hand, a problem that is not well defined, may result in failure to reach the proper countermeasure. To identify and agree on the problem to solve, the teams should spend a few minutes clearly stating the problem, highlighting the ‘what’, ‘where’, ‘when’, and ‘impact’ as succinctly as they can.

Step 2: Apply root-cause analysis and 5 whys

The Root-cause analysis and the ‘5 Whys’ technique is used to explore the cause-and-effect relationships underlying a particular problem. It helps to avoid assumptions and logic traps, trace the chain of causality in direct increments from the effect to a root cause.

The root cause analysis (fishbone or Ishikawa) diagram features 5 main ‘bones’ that represent typical sources of problems in development (tools, people, program, process, environment). Team members then brainstorm causes that they think contribute to the problem to be solved and group them into these categories. Once a cause is identified, its root cause is explored with the 5 Whys technique. By simply asking ‘why’ multiple times, the cause of the previous cause is uncovered, and added to the diagram. The process stops once a suitable root cause has been identified and the same process is then applied to the next cause (© Scaled Agile, Inc.).

Step 3: Identify the biggest root-cause using Pareto analysis

Team uses Pareto analysis (or 80/20 rule) to narrow down the number of actions that produce the most significant overall effect. It is based on the principle that 20% of root causes can cause 80% of problems and it has proved useful where many possible sources and actions are competing. Once the team writes down all the causes-of-causes, they identify the biggest root-cause using dot-voting – every team member has five dots on its disposal, and he can allocate them to one or more items he thinks are most problematic. Then they summarize votes in Pareto chart that shows collective consensus on the most significant root-cause.

Step 4: Restate the new problem for the biggest root-cause

Team picks the most voted item from Pareto chart. They restate it clearly as a problem and add economic impact of the problem to the description.

Step 5: Brainstorm solutions

During the brainstorming activity that lasts about 15 – 30 minutes, team brainstorms as many possible corrective actions as possible. The goal of activity is to generate as many ideas as possible, without criticism or debate. Team members should let their imagination soar and explore and combine all the ideas that arise and in the end dot-vote to identify top contenders.

Step 6: Identify improvement backlog items (NRFs)

In the end of the problem-solving workshop, up to three most voted solutions are identified. Solutions are then rephrased as improvement stories and features to be fed directly into the PI Planning event that follows the I & A event. During that event, the RTE helps ensure that the relevant work needed to deliver the identified improvements is planned. This closes the loop, thus ensuring that action will be taken, and that people and resources are dedicated as necessary to improve the current state. In this way, problem-solving becomes routine and systematic, and team members and ART stakeholders can be assured that the train is solidly on its journey of relentless improvement (© Scaled Agile, Inc. ).

You may also like

Mastering SAFe: What Every Business Professional Should Know

Anti-Patterns in SAFe Implementation

Implementing Inspect and Adapt in SAFe

Table of contents, popular posts, recent posts, why pi objectives matter: discover their importance, safe popm vs. cspo: which certification to choose, safe product manager: key responsibilities explained, csm vs safe certification: which is right for you, safe scrum master roles and responsibilities explained.

Key Highlights

• The Inspect and Adapt (I&A) event is a significant part the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe), teams reflect, evaluate and identify improvement backlog.
• Inspect and Adapt promotes continuous improvement, aligning with the Agile Manifesto’s principle of regularly on how to become effective.
• I plays a crucial role in teams and Agile Releaseains (ARTs) by providing structured time to identify improvements across multiple teams.
• The key components of the Inspect and Adapt process include the PI System Demo, quantitative and qualitative metrics, and conducting effective retrospectives.
• Creating a culture of continuous improvement is essential for the success of Inspect and Adapt, empowering teams and integrating solutions into the workflow.
• Advanced strategies for Inspect and Adapt include leveraging technology for enhanced transparency and collaboration and scaling the process across multiple ARTs.

Introduction

The Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) is a set of organizational and workflow patterns designed to guide organizations in scaling Lean and Agile development practices. One of the significant events in SAFe is the Inspect and Adapt (I&A) event, held at the end of each Program Increment (PI). I&A provides a structured opportunity for teams to reflect, evaluate, and identify improvement backlog items. This blog will explore the implementation of Inspect and Adapt in SAFe, highlighting its importance and key components.

Understanding the Inspect and Adapt Mechanism in SAFe

The Inspect and Adapt (I&A) mechanism in SAFe is a fundamental part of the continuous improvement process. It involves reflecting on the current state of the solution, identifying areas for improvement, and taking action to adapt and enhance the solution. By inspecting the progress and performance of the Agile teams and Agile Release Trains (ARTs), organizations can continuously iterate and refine their processes. This mechanism ensures that teams regularly assess their work, identify bottlenecks or areas for improvement, and adapt their practices to achieve better outcomes.

The Philosophy Behind Inspect and Adapt

The philosophy behind Inspect and Adapt aligns with the Agile Manifesto’s principle of continuous improvement. It emphasizes the value of relentless improvement, where teams continuously reflect on their work and adjust their behavior to become more effective. Inspect and Adapt provides a structured approach to implement this philosophy, ensuring that teams have dedicated time to evaluate their work, identify areas for improvement, and make necessary adjustments. By embracing the philosophy of continuous improvement, organizations can foster a culture of learning and growth, driving better results and increased customer value.

The Role of Inspect and Adapt in Agile Teams and Agile Release Trains (ARTs)

Inspect and Adapt plays a crucial role in Agile teams and Agile Release Trains (ARTs). It provides a dedicated time for teams to reflect on their work, evaluate their performance, and identify areas for improvement. By involving all ART stakeholders, including team members, business owners, and management, in the Inspect and Adapt event, organizations ensure that every ART improves every Program Increment (PI). This collaborative approach enables teams to align their efforts, share learnings, and drive continuous improvement across the entire ART. Inspect and Adapt also promotes transparency and accountability, allowing team members to take ownership of their work and contribute to the overall success of the Agile Release Train.

Key Components of the Inspect and Adapt Process

The Inspect and Adapt process consists of several key components. The first component is the PI System Demo, where the current state of the solution is demonstrated and evaluated. This demo showcases the features developed during the Program Increment (PI) and provides an opportunity for stakeholders to provide feedback. The second component involves quantitative and qualitative measurement, where teams review metrics and data to assess their performance. The final component is the retrospective and problem-solving workshop, where teams identify significant issues and work collaboratively to address them. These key components ensure a structured and comprehensive approach to continuous improvement.

The PI System Demo: Showcasing Achievements and Learning

The PI System Demo is a crucial part of the Inspect and Adapt process. It allows teams to showcase their achievements and learnings from the Program Increment (PI). Here are some key points about the PI System Demo:

• The PI System Demo is a formal demonstration of the features developed during the PI.
• It involves a broader audience, including customers, business owners, and stakeholders.
• The demo is timeboxed to keep stakeholders engaged and provide feedback.
• Business owners collaborate with each Agile Team to score the actual business value achieved for each Team PI Objective.
• The PI System Demo helps stakeholders understand the progress and value delivered by the Agile teams.

Quantitative and Qualitative Metrics: Measuring Success

Measuring success is an essential aspect of the Inspect and Adapt process. Quantitative and qualitative metrics are used to assess the performance of Agile teams and ARTs. These metrics provide valuable insights into the progress and effectiveness of the work. Here are some key points about measuring success through metrics:

• Quantitative metrics, such as predictability, help evaluate how well the teams meet their commitments.
• Qualitative metrics, such as actual business value, provide insights into the value delivered to stakeholders.
• Metrics enable organizations to identify trends, potential issues, and areas for improvement.
• The RTE and Solution Train Engineer are responsible for gathering and analyzing the metrics to facilitate data-driven decision-making.
• Measuring success through metrics allows teams to track their performance and make data-based improvements.

Conducting Effective Retrospectives

Effective retrospectives are a crucial component of the Inspect and Adapt process. Retrospectives provide an opportunity for teams to reflect on their work, identify strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement. Here are some key points about conducting effective retrospectives:

• Retrospectives should be conducted at regular intervals to ensure continuous improvement.
• The Scrum Master or a designated facilitator leads the retrospective process.
• Team members actively participate and contribute their insights, experiences, and suggestions.
• Retrospectives allow teams to celebrate achievements, address challenges, and generate improvement items.
• The retrospective process encourages open communication, collaboration, and a shared commitment to continuous learning and growth.

Best Practices for Facilitating Retrospectives

Facilitating effective retrospectives requires careful planning and execution. Here are some best practices for facilitating retrospectives:

• Define the purpose and goals of the retrospective to ensure clarity and focus.
• Create a safe and open environment where team members feel comfortable sharing their thoughts and ideas.
• Use various retrospective formats, such as the Start, Stop, Continue technique or the Mad, Sad, Glad method, to encourage participation and generate meaningful insights.
• Encourage active participation from all team members, ensuring that everyone’s voice is heard.
• Capture improvement items and prioritize them based on their impact and feasibility.
• Ensure that the retrospective outcomes are communicated and followed up on to drive continuous improvement.

Common Challenges and Solutions

Implementing Inspect and Adapt may come with its challenges. Here are some common challenges and their potential solutions:

• Identifying systemic problems: It can be challenging to identify underlying issues that contribute to recurring problems. Using problem-solving techniques like root-cause analysis and the 5 Whys can help uncover the root causes.
• Problem-solving buy-in: Getting buy-in from team members and stakeholders can be a challenge. Engaging them in the problem-solving process from the beginning and demonstrating the value of their input can help overcome this challenge.
• Implementing solutions: Ensuring that identified solutions are implemented effectively can be a challenge. Creating improvement backlog items and integrating them into the workflow during PI Planning helps prioritize and allocate resources for implementing the solutions.

The Problem-Solving Workshop Explained

The problem-solving workshop is a structured approach to address systemic problems identified during the retrospective. Here’s an overview of the problem-solving workshop:

• Facilitated by the RTE, the problem-solving workshop aims to identify the root causes of the identified problems.
• The workshop typically follows a timebox of two hours or less.
• Problem-solving tools like the fishbone diagram (Ishikawa diagram) and the 5 Whys technique are used to explore and uncover the root causes.
• The workshop encourages cross-functional collaboration and enables teams to address problems collectively.

Identifying and Agreeing on the Problem(s) to Solve

To ensure effective problem-solving, it is crucial to identify and agree on the problem(s) to solve. Here are some key points for identifying and agreeing on the problem(s) to solve:

• Clearly state the problem, including the ‘what,’ ‘where,’ ‘when,’ and ‘impact’ to ensure a shared understanding.
• Spend time discussing and clarifying the problem to ensure alignment among team members.
• Involve key stakeholders, including business owners and those impacted by the problem, to gain diverse perspectives.
• Agreement on the problem(s) lays the foundation for effective problem-solving and ensures a focused approach.

Performing Root Cause Analysis with Your Team

Performing root cause analysis is a crucial step in problem-solving. Here are some key points for performing root cause analysis with your team:

• Use tools like the fishbone diagram (Ishikawa diagram) to identify potential causes and categorize them into people, processes, tools, program, and environment.
• Brainstorm potential causes and explore them using the 5 Whys technique.
• Engage team members to contribute their perspectives and insights during the analysis process.
• The goal is to uncover the root cause rather than addressing the symptoms of the problem.
• Root cause analysis helps teams gain a deeper understanding of the problem and identify effective solutions.

Brainstorming and Prioritizing Solutions

Once the root causes are identified, the next step is to brainstorm and prioritize solutions. Here are some key points for brainstorming and prioritizing solutions:

• Encourage a creative and open environment for brainstorming ideas.
• Generate as many possible solutions as possible within a fixed timebox.
• Prioritize the solutions based on their impact, feasibility, and potential to address the root causes.
• Consider involving key stakeholders to gain diverse perspectives and ensure alignment.
• The prioritized solutions serve as improvement backlog items and are planned during the next PI Planning event.

Creating a Culture of Continuous Improvement

Creating a culture of continuous improvement is essential for the success of Inspect and Adapt. Here’s why:

• Continuous improvement ensures that teams consistently evaluate their work and make necessary adjustments.
• Relentless improvement, driven by a culture of continuous learning, fosters innovation and growth.
• Teams are empowered to take ownership of their work and actively contribute to improving processes and outcomes.
• Leadership plays a crucial role in promoting a culture of continuous improvement and providing support and resources for ongoing learning and growth.

From Problems to Backlog: Integrating Solutions into Your Workflow

Integrating solutions into the workflow is essential to ensure that identified improvements are implemented effectively. Here are some key points for integrating solutions into your workflow:

• Capture the prioritized solutions as improvement backlog items.
• Prioritize the improvement backlog items based on their impact and feasibility during PI Planning.
• Allocate resources and plan the necessary work to implement the solutions.
• Regularly review and update the improvement backlog to ensure progress and accountability.
• Integrating solutions into the workflow ensures that the identified improvements are actively pursued and contribute to the continuous improvement process.

Empowering Teams for Long-Term Success

Empowering teams is crucial for their long-term success and the success of the Inspect and Adapt process. Here are some key points on empowering teams:

• Provide teams with autonomy and decision-making authority to take ownership of their work.
• Encourage collaboration and create a safe environment where team members feel empowered to contribute their ideas and insights.
• Foster a growth mindset and encourage continuous learning and professional development.
• Recognize and celebrate team achievements, fostering a sense of accomplishment and motivation.
• Empowered teams are more likely to drive continuous improvement, adapt to change, and achieve long-term success.

Advanced Strategies for Inspect and Adapt

Advanced strategies can further enhance the effectiveness of the Inspect and Adapt process. Here are some key advanced strategies:

• Leverage technology for enhanced transparency and collaboration, enabling teams to track progress and share learnings more effectively.
• Scale the Inspect and Adapt process across multiple Agile Release Trains (ARTs), ensuring synchronization and alignment.
• Emphasize knowledge sharing and cross-training between ARTs to foster collaboration and continuous improvement.
• Implement advanced problem-solving techniques, such as Six Sigma or Lean Six Sigma, to drive more in-depth analysis and improvement efforts.
• By adopting these advanced strategies, organizations can take their Inspect and Adapt process to the next level and drive even greater value.

Leveraging Technology for Enhanced Transparency and Collaboration

Technology can play a vital role in enhancing the effectiveness of the Inspect and Adapt process. Here are some key points on leveraging technology:

• Use collaborative platforms or software tools to facilitate transparency and information sharing among teams and stakeholders.
• Implement visual dashboards or Kanban boards to track progress, metrics, and improvement backlog items.
• Leverage video conferencing or virtual collaboration tools to enable remote teams to actively participate in Inspect and Adapt events.
• Implement data analytics or reporting tools to analyze quantitative and qualitative metrics and identify trends or areas for improvement.
• By leveraging technology, organizations can enhance transparency, collaboration, and data-driven decision-making in the Inspect and Adapt process.

Scaling the Inspect and Adapt Process Across Multiple ARTs

Scaling the Inspect and Adapt process across multiple Agile Release Trains (ARTs) requires synchronization and alignment. Here are some key points on scaling the process:

• Establish a common PI cadence and ensure that all ARTs align their Inspect and Adapt events accordingly.
• Foster collaboration and knowledge sharing across ARTs to leverage insights and best practices.
• Implement a governance structure to facilitate coordination and decision-making across ARTs.
• Utilize dedicated resources, such as Release Train Engineers (RTEs), to ensure the smooth execution of Inspect and Adapt events across multiple ARTs.
• Scaling the Inspect and Adapt process across multiple ARTs enables organizations to drive continuous improvement on a larger scale and maximize the value delivered.

In conclusion, the Inspect and Adapt process in SAFe is a crucial mechanism that nurtures a culture of continuous improvement within Agile teams and Agile Release Trains. By emphasizing retrospectives, problem-solving workshops, and creating a space for learning and growth, organizations can achieve enhanced collaboration and measurable success. Leveraging advanced strategies like technology integration and scaling across multiple ARTs further strengthens the impact of Inspect and Adapt. Addressing common challenges and fostering a mindset of adaptability ensures long-term success in achieving organizational goals through iterative improvements.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should inspect and adapt sessions be held.

Inspect and Adapt sessions should be held at the end of each Program Increment (PI). This cadence ensures regular intervals for teams to reflect, evaluate, and identify improvement backlog items. It serves as a significant event that aligns with the continuous improvement philosophy of SAFe.

Can Inspect and Adapt be applied to non-IT projects in SAFe?

Yes, Inspect and Adapt can be applied to non-IT projects within the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe). The adaptability of SAFe allows organizations to tailor the Inspect and Adapt process to various domains and industries, enabling continuous improvement and value delivery beyond the IT sector.

What are the common pitfalls to avoid during the Inspect and Adapt process?

Some common pitfalls to avoid during the Inspect and Adapt process include:

• Lack of stakeholder involvement and buy-in
• Insufficient time allocated for reflection and problem-solving
• Failure to prioritize and implement identified improvement backlog items
• Lack of continuous tracking and follow-up on improvement efforts

How can remote teams effectively participate in Inspect and Adapt events?

Remote teams can effectively participate in Inspect and Adapt events by leveraging virtual collaboration tools, video conferencing, and shared document platforms. Ensuring clear communication, providing equal opportunities for participation, and utilizing technology can bridge the gap and promote active involvement.

How does Inspect and Adapt contribute to the overall success of an Agile Release Train?

Inspect and Adapt contributes to the overall success of an Agile Release Train (ART) by driving continuous improvement. It provides dedicated time for teams to reflect, evaluate, and identify improvement backlog items. By actively embracing and implementing improvements, ARTs can enhance their performance, deliver better outcomes, and continuously increase customer value.

What is the first step for a team new to the Inspect and Adapt process?

The first step for a team new to the Inspect and Adapt process is to familiarize themselves with the process and its objectives. Understanding the purpose and benefits of Inspect and Adapt lays the foundation for effective participation and engagement in the continuous improvement efforts.

Popular Courses

About the author.

You may also be interested in:

Key Highlights PI Objectives summarize the business and technical goals that teams and trains intend to achieve in the upcoming Program Increment (PI) They provide

Key Highlights SAFe POPM CSPO are two certifications for product owners project managers in the Scrum and Agile frameworks. SAFe POPM focuses on scaled Agile

Key Highlights A SAFe Product Manager plays a role in the scaled framework, working closely with agile teams to ensure the successful delivery of products.

Kanban Management Professional (KMP)

Kanban Systems Improvement (KMP2/KSI)

Kanban System Design (KMP1/KSD)

Team Kanban Practitioner (TKP)

Enterprise Solutions

• Corporate Training
• Become a Trainer

© 2024 AgileFever. All Rights Reserved by AgileFever . 

Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions

Course Category

We value your privacy

Dial +1 93133 04939 or Click to initiate call

Contact Course Advisor

What's on your mind, enquiry for corporate training.

" * " indicates required fields

[email protected]

+91 9036707847

Recent Posts

• Differences between Salesforce Sal..
• How to Learn Salesforce Marketing ..
• Benefits of Salesforce Marketing C..
• What Exactly Does Salesforce Do? A..
• Snowflake Learning Path: A Compreh..
• Artificial Intelligence, Automatio..
• The Future of AI in Education: Rev..
• Artificial Intelligence and the Fu..
• Do's and Don'ts in Programmatic Ad..
• Best Programmatic Advertising Plat..

Inspect and Adapt in Scaled Agile Framework

The Scaled Agile Framework is a grouping of patterns for organization and workflow developed to help enterprises scale Lean and Agile development practices. This is one of the most popular frameworks whose objective is to help organizations face the challenges in their effort to scale Agile beyond one team. Agile teams work through a regular feedback system, and feedback comes in many ways. One way is receiving product feedback at the end of every iteration when the iteration review is done. Another way of receiving feedback is during the iteration retrospective, where there is an opportunity to review and improve people and processes. Through this continuous feedback, teams keep improving and improving, which helps them build better products. 

But in SAFe, many teams work together on one product. So, the Agile Release Train (ART) also needs to get into a feedback system. There are many principles, practices, and events within the Scaled Agile Framework; if not all, most are used when large-scale product production. For example, events like iteration reviews and retrospectives in SAFe occur after the end of the iterations. Inspect and Adapt Scaled Agile Framework is also an event that happens at the end of a Program Increment (PI). Here, we will provide all the details about the SAFe Agile Inspect and Adapt (I&A), including what happens. 

What is Scaled Agile Inspect and Adapt?

Described by Scaled Agile as "a significant event that is held at the end of each Program Iteration," Inspect and Adapt is a crucial feature of SAFe, where PI is a timeboxed event that is usually of 8 to 12 weeks duration. As the name suggests, it is an event to inspect the product's progress and condition and adapt to the new features. The purpose of a PI is to enable the Agile Release Train to deliver incremental value at the end of this event which is in the form of a working and tested product or service. This value may be some features of the product or service. And the I&A event is held at the end of each PI so that developers can show at what stage the product development has reached and what process was used to reach this condition. The ART then evaluates the product. This is followed by a structured problem-solving workshop where teams ponder and identify the improvement backlog items. The I&A event is crucial because it gives the ART a chance to thoroughly inspect both the product and the process, which helps ensure that the following PI would be better. Thorough inspection and efforts to improve both the product and the process will pave the way for a better PI the next time. 

The event is attended by all the Stakeholders in the Agile Release Train, provides a set of improvement backlog items added to the next PI planning event, and helps the ART improve all the subsequent PIs. Solution trains hold a similar I&A event for large solutions. 

Principle of Inspect and Adapt

The basis of the SAFe Lean-Agile strategy is the concept mentioned in the Agile manifesto that states, "continuous improvement is essential ." The teams take time at the pre-decided intervals to contemplate how they can become more effective and efficient. Based on the derived thoughts, they change or modify their behaviors accordingly. This focus on continuous improvement and the experience gathered through the development cycle, along with the repeated review, enhances the teams' ability to find different viewpoints and multiple ways to do one task. So, the I&A event is an ideal chance for the teams to reflect on what has gone wrong so far, the mistakes that have been committed, and the ways to prevent them from happening again. This is further bolstered by the feedback received from different sources that helps them improve the product and the process. The result is an overall improvement in the speed, quality, and reliability of the following PI. So, it is essential to be set apart to think about how teams can improve. 

The Scaled Agile Framework Inspect and Adapt process:

Being an essential element of SAFe, the I&A process drives continuous development with the help of team evaluation and Stakeholder inputs. A team can make continuous progress if a mindset of inspection and adaptation is adopted. All people involved in developing the solution should ideally participate in the I&A event. These include:

The Agile teams

Release Train Engineers (RTEs)

System and solution architects/ Engineers

Product management

Business owners and others in the ART

The I&A event works in three parts. They are:

The PI system demonstration - Analyzing and customizing the product

Qualitative and quantitative measurement - Analyzing the process with the help of metrics

Retrospectives and workshop on problem-solving strategies - Customizing the process

We will now discuss each part in detail.

The PI system demo:

This is the first part of Inspect and Adapt process. It is the demonstration of the system developed during the PI. Here, product development facilitates demonstration covering the fully integrated system. This system demo is a biweekly event but differs from the system demos held at the end of every PI. This demo aims to demonstrate all the features developed by the ART during the just concluded PI. The ultimate goal is to display the existing condition of the system and the progress it has made. The audience here is much broader than the normal PIs and includes business owners, Stakeholders, sponsors, portfolio representatives, and customer representatives. All these collaborate with every Agile team to assess how much business value has been delivered. So, this demo takes a more formal shape and needs extra preparation and staging. Despite this, the PI system demo is time-bound, like other demos, usually limited to, at the most, one hour. An exception can be made for Stakeholders to remain actively engaged and provide feedback. 

The Agile team should present their part of the features quickly so that the whole exercise finishes within an hour. The demonstration by every team can earn some appreciation after its presentation, but the main point of interest should be that the result connects everything. The whole exercise aims to keep the audience engaged in giving proper feedback. So, every team should ensure its presentation is precise and to the point and doesn't get stuck in too many facts. For this purpose, teams should employ creative techniques to keep the audience hooked.  In the end, all the members collaborate to assess how much business value has been delivered up to this point. An essential aspect of the PI system demo is that before or during the demo, Business Owners and the Agile team give a score to the business value achieved during the PI for every individual objective of that particular PI.

Quantitative and qualitative measurement:

This is the next part of Inspect and Adapt scaled Agile . The teams have already agreed to collect data that can be used as metrics. In this part, all the teams sit together to review the metrics and then discuss the emerging data and trends. The responsibility of collecting and analyzing these metrics lies with the Release Train Engineer and the Solution Train Engineer, who must ensure that these align with the business objectives. They are also responsible for identifying the potential issues from these data and trends and presenting their findings to the ART. The products performance and processes that have been part of this ART is measured against these metrics from both quantitative and qualitative viewpoints. Suppose the teams need help deciding which metrics they should collect and analyze. In that case, the Scaled Agile Framework Metrics page provides an exhaustive list of the different portfolio, solution, program, enterprise, and team metrics they can use.

But be mindful of one thing, whatever you may choose to measure, numbers won't reveal everything. Instead, Metrics can be used to uncover the whole story, which can be done by scrutinizing the metrics. This is another session that lasts for one hour, where Program/ART level metrics are displayed to the audience. The program Predictability Measure is one of the critical measurements carried out in this phase. The program predictability measure is developed by expanding the value planned and the actual value achieved by each team. Each team's predictability is measured based on the value delivered by that team, and then the overall program predictability is consolidated. The trains operating within the 80-100% range are considered reliable. Some qualitative measurements can also be taken by the ARTs, like product delivery assessments, Agile assessments, and assessments specific to roles.

Retrospectives and problem-solving:

The first thing the teams do in the Retrospective part of Inspect and Adapt is to find out the problems and process issues they think need to be addressed. They then narrow this to some significant issues at either the team or the program level. These issues are then addressed in the problem-solving workshop. The retrospective runs for about 30 minutes. Issues at the program level usually are addressed by participants of those cross-functional teams that are directly and immediately affected by these issues and, thus are more inspired to resolve them. This creates a broader collection of perspectives and possible solutions that are creative and better. So once the problems are identified, the group is aided by the facilitator, who helps them decide on the issues they want to address. Then, either each team works on one issue or new people from different teams interested in working on the same problem form some new groups. In this phase, the Agile teams are joined by the primary Stakeholders in the ART, like business owners, management, and customers.

Once the retrospective is completed, it is followed by a problem-solving workshop held by ART, in which systemic problems are addressed through root-cause analysis. This root cause analysis brings forward specific tools for resolving issues that help the teams identify the problem's real cause. The Release Train Engineer is tasked with arranging and facilitating this work, typically held over two hours.

Begin with an explicit description of the issue and a commitment to resolving it.

Then do a root-cause analysis putting the issue on the top, and the factors instrumental in its emergence, including people, processes, resources, or systems, are listed along its branches.

Pareto analysis is then used to determine the primary cause that is most impactful at this point. 

Now that the problem has been presented transparently, next, teams can brainstorm to find a possible solution to the problem.

Once the solution is found, the schedule's components are readjusted so they can be incorporated into the following PI.

The tools used during the problem-solving workshop include Pareto analysis, Fish-bone or Ishikawa diagram, and/or 5Whys technique. With this exercise, the cycle of relentless improvement comes alive.

Adopting Lean-Agile thinking and practices takes time and many of the best methods. And the SAFe Inspect and Adapt is a crucial part of it. It assures the business owners that the products and the processes are moving in the right direction. The Agile Release Trains become stronger and at the same time, it makes sure that the SAFe framework guidelines are being followed correctly. The teams are driven to provide their best

Want to Level Up Your Skills?

LearnNThrive is a global training and placement provider helping the graduates to pick the best technology trainings and certification programs. Have queries? Get In touch!

Useful Links

Trending Courses

Popular courses.

Designed, Developed & Marketing by KandraDigital

Copyright 2024 © LearnNThrive Solutions Private Limited

Don’t Miss Out Mind Blowing Benefits

• Pay Later and EMI Options
• Exclusive Discounts for Group Registration
• Competitive Custom Quotes for Corporates
• Complimentary Training Sessions
• Free Passes to Trending Training Programs
• Access to Engaging Webinars
• Flexible Curriculum & Schedules
• Earn Referral Bonuses and More!

Take The Lowest Price Challenge! Submit your quote or price looking for and get the best deal.

Thank you !

Our course advisor will be in touch with you shortly to provide all the necessary information regarding your query.

In the meantime, feel free to contact us at [email protected] for any further inquiries or assistance. We also encourage you to explore our social media pages and follow us for updates on course testimonials, special offers, and exciting updates. Stay connected for valuable information and more!

Five Things You May Not Know About the SAFe Inspect and Adapt (I&A) Event

The Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe … the “e” means nothing…) is the industry leading framework for scaling agile in a business or business unit. It’s used by some pretty big names like CVS, American Express, and FedEx.

Emma Ropski

The Scaled Agile Frame work (SAFe) incorporates methods, events, principles, and roles that agilists are already familiar with from Scrum, Lean, and XP. But SAFe is also novel, with its own unique concepts, roles, and events like the Inspect and Adapt (I&A) , a reflective all hands event that happens every quarter featuring a problem solving workshop. 

The thing about SAFe events is, even if you know a bit about them, they can still be super mysterious. It’s like a nursing student who’s only read their textbook or a rock and roll fan who’s never been to a Grateful Dead concert. You really have to be there to get it.

 Lucky for you, I have been there! Over ten times as both a participant and a facilitator! Here are a few misconceptions.

The I&A is more than just the problem solving workshop

People often use the term I&A to mean just the problem solving workshop. Though that is the main attraction of the 4-hour event, you’re missing some of the context setting that happens earlier in the agenda. 

First, there’s a demo of the current state of the product, highlighting work done in the past quarter. Next, the group reviews select success and predictability metrics focusing on areas to improve. Then, some do a retrospective during the event time-box to brainstorm and form problem statements. And finally, we get to the problem solving workshop!

• Become THE Expert!
• Subscribe to ScatterSpoke's Newsletter for more expert advice, and recieve a FREE copy of our popular Icebreakers List.
• Become an Expert!

You don’t need to use an Ishikawa diagram!

An Ishikawa diagram, also known as a fishbone diagram, is recommended for small groups to use to visualize potential contributing causes of the problem to be solved. The group then explores the causes of the causes using the five whys technique to get to a root cause. (Say causes of the causes five times fast). Though it may seem excessive to some, going deeper helps ensure that we're tackling the disease and not just a symptom of it. The group then diverges and converges on a solution set.

This fishbone visualization combined with the described technique is recommended because it is effective and theoretically sound. But fishbone quarter after quarter can leave teammates uninspired and asking, “… is there anything besides fish on the menu?” 

I’ve seen a few other approaches to keep things fresh and keep morale up. My first I&A problem solving workshop was unlike any other. They gave all randomly assigned groups this prompt: “ You have all the money and resources you desire… How do you take our company down?" Let’s just say the room was buzzing! Though not traditional by any means, this alternative method still met the purpose of the event: to reflect and identify ways to improve. 

Problems don’t actually get solved in the workshop

With a name like “problem-solving workshop,” you’d think you solve problems. A more accurate name would be “problem exploring and solution proposal workshop,” but that really doesn’t have the same ring to it.

Let me explain. In the problem-solving workshop, the problems proposed should be experienced cross-team and are usually systemic. Their root causes often lie in culture, process, or environment. They’re big problems! Realistically, some could take years to properly solve. 

The vast majority of the time-box in the workshop is allotted to identifying these root causes. Even with less time, groups tend to brainstorm multiple possible solutions and present their top ideas to the whole group. Since problems are big, often the first step in the solution is to explore the problem more.

So, what’s the point? In my opinion, the problem-solving workshop raises problems to the surface and gets the conversation started. The “solving” often takes some more time, coordination, and prioritization.

Some people can’t participate

…. because they facilitate! Scrum masters, coaches, and other volunteers are usually necessary to guide small groups through a typical problem solving workshop. Why? To avoid the chaos that can often occur in group discussions:

         • dominating the conversation and others not feeling safe to share

         • Groups getting off topic due to confusion or boredom

         • Skipping “less exciting” steps like problem exploration to get to “more exciting” steps like solutioning 

Still, knowing some teammates aren’t engaged in problem solving can feel like a disservice to the whole group. Everyone has experiences, knowledge, and context to add to the collective pool of knowledge which would contribute to a more holistic and, therefore, successful solution. My advice? Rotate facilitators every quarter when possible, especially if they aren’t in a dedicated coaching role.

It takes a lot of behind the scenes work to make the I&A happen.

Though many will just show up, listen, and problem solve with their teammates at the end of the quarter, the I&A event requires several people several hours to prepare for. 

Product management is usually accountable for the demo though may get some support from scrum masters. They usually connect with teams, team leads, and feature-owners to coordinate a demo (ideally live and not death by PowerPoint) of the holistic product, highlighting new features delivered this quarter.

Good data doesn’t just happen; it’s quite intentional. Success and predictability metrics should be agreed upon and defined before the quarter, ideally as a constant to compare quarter to quarter. Once collected and visualized, it needs to be presented in a way that is concise and motivating regardless of the results. Not an easy task.

Retrospective

Running a 30-minute retrospective with 100 people on identifying and defining systemic problems experienced across several teams in the last 3 months is a tall task. With the teams I’ve been on, usually we’ve taken the extra step ahead of the I&A to gather problem statements. As the scrum master, I’d design and facilitate a retro of the past three months and coach teams through what’s an appropriate problem to bring and the information it needs. It’s still a tall task, but a little less tall. We could make the task even shorter by using ScatterSpoke’s Team Pulse 👀

Designing the format, forming the small groups, training the facilitators, collecting improvement items, voting on them, and finding a way to squeeze them into an already tight backlog is all in a day’s work for the coach leading this event. Just reading it all makes me sweat!

Even if you haven’t been there, with the inside scoop from me, the I&A in practice should be a bit demystified. It’s not just a problem-solving workshop. And the problem-solving workshop isn’t really a problem solving workshop. You can vary the protein served beyond fish, and not everyone gets to eat (but definitely next time!). Last but not least, preparing for the I&A takes time, energy, and passion. Systemic problems aren’t easy, but this unique SAFe event is an inclusive and brave first step toward solving them.

Related Posts

The power of developer feedback.

Listening to team feedback is essential in tech for building high-quality software and staying competitive. Developers and support teams provide practical, hands-on insights that can lead to immediate improvements. Creating a continuous feedback loop, acting on the feedback, and building trust within the team are critical steps for fostering a culture of continuous improvement and collaboration.

Why Quarterly Retrospectives Guarantee Nothing Ever Changes in Agile Release Trains

Quarterly feedback may align with SAFe's Program Increments, but it can hinder the success of Agile Release Trains. Discover how Agile Delivery Managers and RTEs can drive continuous improvement through frequent retrospectives and actionable insights. Learn why embracing agility and faster feedback loops is crucial for your organization's growth and success.

John Samuelson

How scatterspoke developers improved flow state time with ai coding assistant cody.

The developers at ScatterSpoke enhanced their flow state time and sped up their delivery process by integrating an AI coding assistant named Cody, which helped automate repetitive tasks, provide code suggestions, and quick-fix common errors. As a result, their workflow improved significantly with increased productivity, enhanced knowledge, improved focus, and reduced coding errors, leading to the delivery of high-quality software products.

Act On Feedback Faster

Join the ranks of data-driven companies seamlessly acting on feedback and driving substantial improvement with less effort.

ScatterSpoke helps you eliminate waste in your dev process.

© XXXX ScatterSpoke. All Rights Reserved.

Lean Agile Guru

Lean Agile Ideas Worth Spreading For The SAFe Enterprise

• Lean Agile Software Factory
• New Book! The Inner and Outer Game Of SAFe 6.0
• Merchandise
• SAFe Classes
• Meet The Guru
• Testimonials
• Free Members Only
• Platinum Members Only
• Elite Circle Members Only
• Login/Logout
• Your Partner
• Take Action

Drive Relentless Improvement via ‘Inspect and Adapt’

Application: the famous Plan, Do, Check, Adjust/Adapt (PDCA) is a learning cycle…things are inspected and adaptation follows based on what has been learned and observed. This cycle occurs at every level be it team level, program level, or solution level… hence the mantra ‘Inspect and Adapt’ for relentless and continuous improvement.

At the program Level of SAFe, there is a program event called ‘Inspect and Adapt (I&A)’. No surprise there. The purpose of which is exactly that, to pursue relentless and continuous improvement.

It comes in three parts: 1) the system demo; 2) the quantitative measurement; 3) retrospective and problem solving workshop.

Remember relentless and continuous improvement? Yeah…make sure that you put the improvement items to the team/program improvement backlog and roadmap… and address / act upon these… otherwise, what’s the point of having this ‘Inspect and Adapt’?

Kaizen is about changing the way things are. If you assume that things are all right the way they are, you can’t do kaizen. So change something! —Taiichi Ohno

You will get a FREE SIGNED COPY if/when you register, pay, and complete a class by the Lean Agile Guru .

Share this:

By Clarence Galapon

CE, MBA, Lean Agile Coach, Trainer, Teacher, SPC, RTE, PSM, PMI-ACP, PMI-PBA, PMP, CC, ABNLP NLP (Neuro Linguistic Programming) Practitioner, NLP Coach, NLP Trainer, Practical Psychologist, Life Coach, Software Executive, Entrepreneur, Author, Investor, and Innovator with a Creative, Lean, Agile, and Wander mindset. https://LeanAgileGuru.com

Related Posts

Start With The End In Mind

The Snowball Effect

When is Inspect and Adapt?

Remember me

Forgot Password?

Discover more from Lean Agile Guru

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Type your email…

Continue reading

Supercharge Agile Success with SAFe Inspect and Adapt

• On May 14, 2023
• By David Usifo (PSM, MBCS, PMP®)

The key to thriving in today’s rapidly changing business environment is adapting quickly to meet new challenges and opportunities.

Agile methodologies, such as the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe), provide organizations with the tools they need to stay competitive and responsive.

One of the most critical components of SAFe is the Inspect and Adapt (I&A) process, which promotes continuous improvement and learning.

In this comprehensive blog post, we will explore the SAFe Inspect and Adapt process in-depth, guiding you through its principles, phases, benefits, and practical tips for success.

Table of Contents

What is SAFe?

The Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) is a set of principles, processes, and best practices designed to help organizations scale Agile practices across the enterprise.

SAFe provides a structured approach to align multiple teams and coordinate their efforts, ensuring a consistent delivery of value to customers.

It emphasizes collaboration, communication, and transparency, making it easier for large organizations to adopt Agile methodologies and stay competitive in the market.

Inspect and Adapt in SAFe

Inspect and Adapt (I&A) is a key principle and event in the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) that emphasizes the importance of continuous improvement within an organization.

The I&A event or workshop is designed to help Agile Release Trains (ARTs) and other stakeholders regularly assess their progress, identify areas for improvement, and make necessary adjustments to their processes and plans.

This iterative approach ensures that teams stay aligned with their goals, learn from their experiences, and adapt as needed to optimize performance and outcomes.

The Inspect and Adapt event is structured to facilitate reflection, analysis, and action. It is held at the end of each Program Increment (PI) , which typically lasts 8-12 weeks, and involves the participation of all ART members, as well as Product Management, and other key stakeholders.

The event provides a formal opportunity for teams to:

1. Inspect their Work

Teams evaluate the work they have completed during the PI, assessing the quality and effectiveness of the solutions developed, as well as progress towards their objectives.

This involves reviewing both the tangible outputs (e.g., features, user stories ) and the underlying processes used to create them.

2. Adapt their approach

Based on the insights gained from the inspection, teams identify areas where improvements can be made, and develop action plans to address them.

This may involve adjusting their processes, tools, or strategies, as well as resolving any impediments or issues that have been identified.

By regularly engaging in the Inspect and Adapt process, organizations can cultivate a culture of continuous learning and improvement, enabling them to more effectively respond to change, address challenges, and achieve their desired outcomes.

The I&A event in SAFe reinforces the Agile principles of transparency, feedback, and adaptation, helping organizations to become more resilient, adaptive, and successful in today’s rapidly-evolving business environment.

Phases of the SAFe Inspect and Adapt Event

The Inspect and Adapt event is divided into three primary phases or components:

1. PI System Demo

The PI System Demo is an opportunity for Agile Release Trains (ARTs) to showcase the work they’ve accomplished during the Program Increment (PI).

This demo is a critical aspect of the I&A event, as it enables teams to:

• Gather feedback from stakeholders, which can be used to make improvements in the next PI.
• Validate that the developed features meet the customers’ needs and expectations.
• Ensure that the different teams’ work is integrated and functioning as a cohesive system.
• Promote transparency and foster a shared understanding of the progress made during the PI.

2. Quantitative Measurement

Quantitative measurement is an essential part of the I&A event, as it helps teams objectively evaluate their performance and progress.

Some common quantitative measurements used in SAFe include:

• Program Predictability Measure : This metric compares the actual business value delivered by the ART against the planned business value.
• Agile Metrics : These may include lead time, cycle time, team velocity , and other metrics that help assess the efficiency and effectiveness of the Agile teams.
• Quality Metrics : These can include defect counts, escaped defects, test coverage, and other indicators that measure product quality and reliability.
• DevOps Metrics : These may include deployment frequency, change lead time, change failure rate, and mean time to recovery, which help assess the efficiency of the development and operations processes.

These metrics help teams identify strengths and weaknesses, which can then be addressed during the Retrospective and Problem-Solving Workshop.

3. Retrospective and Problem-Solving Workshop

The Retrospective and Problem-Solving Workshop is a structured session where teams reflect on their performance, identify areas of improvement, and create action plans to address them.

The workshop typically follows these steps:

• Identify Improvements : Teams discuss the outcomes of the PI System Demo and the quantitative measurements, highlighting what went well and what needs to be improved.
• Root Cause Analysis : Teams conduct a thorough analysis of the underlying causes of the identified issues, using techniques such as the “5 Whys” or Ishikawa (fishbone) diagram.
• Brainstorm Solutions : Teams collaboratively brainstorm potential solutions to the root causes, considering various perspectives and ideas.
• Prioritize Actions : The team prioritizes the proposed solutions based on factors such as impact, feasibility, and alignment with organizational goals.
• Create Action Plans : For each prioritized solution, teams create an action plan detailing the steps, responsibilities, and timeline for implementation.

The insights and action plans generated during the Retrospective and Problem-Solving Workshop help teams continuously improve and increase their effectiveness in the next PI.

Benefits of the Inspect and Adapt Event to Organizations

The Inspect and Adapt (I&A) event in the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) offers several benefits to organizations, helping them to continuously improve and adapt to the ever-changing business environment.

Some of the key benefits include:

1. Continuous Improvement

The I&A event encourages teams to regularly reflect on their work, identify areas for improvement, and make necessary adjustments.

This fosters a culture of continuous learning and improvement, enabling organizations to optimize their processes and maximize their effectiveness.

2. Enhanced Agility

By embracing the principle of adaptation, organizations can better respond to changes in market conditions, customer needs, and technological advancements.

The I&A event helps organizations stay agile and pivot as needed to maintain alignment with their goals and objectives.

3. Increased Transparency

The I&A event promotes transparency by involving stakeholders in the review and assessment of the work completed during the Program Increment.

This shared understanding of progress and challenges helps build trust, improve collaboration, and ensure that everyone is working towards the same goals.

4. Higher Quality Outcomes

Through regular inspection of work and processes, organizations can identify and address issues that impact product quality.

This focus on quality leads to the delivery of robust and reliable solutions that meet or exceed customer expectations.

5. Better Decision-Making

The I&A event provides valuable data and insights that inform decision-making at both the team and organizational levels.

By using data-driven insights, organizations can make more informed choices that optimize their resources and drive better results.

6. Improved Employee Engagement

The I&A event encourages collaboration and empowers teams to take ownership of their work and improvement initiatives.

This sense of ownership and involvement can lead to higher employee engagement, satisfaction, and retention.

7. Alignment with Organizational Goals

By regularly reviewing progress towards objectives, teams can ensure that their work remains aligned with the organization’s overall goals and strategies.

This alignment helps prevent wasted efforts and ensures that all teams are working together to achieve the desired outcomes.

Tips for a Successful Inspect and Adapt Workshop

To ensure a successful Inspect and Adapt (I&A) workshop in the context of the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe), consider the following tips:

1. Invite Relevant Stakeholders

Ensure that all key stakeholders, such as Agile Release Train (ART) members, Product Management, and other important contributors, attend the I&A workshop.

Their participation will help create a shared understanding of the progress and challenges faced during the Program Increment (PI).

2. Prepare and Share Data

Collect and share relevant quantitative data and performance metrics before the workshop.

This will provide a solid foundation for discussions and help participants understand the context of the issues that need to be addressed.

3. Establish a Safe and Open Environment

Encourage open and honest communication during the workshop. Participants should feel comfortable sharing their thoughts, experiences, and concerns without fear of judgment or retribution.

4. Use Structured Problem-Solving Techniques

Utilize structured problem-solving approaches, such as the “5 Whys” or Ishikawa (fishbone) diagrams, to facilitate root cause analysis of the identified issues and help ensure that the underlying causes are thoroughly investigated and addressed.

5. Focus on Actionable Improvements

Encourage participants to brainstorm and prioritize improvements that are actionable and within the team’s control. The goal is to identify changes that can be implemented in the next PI to drive continuous improvement.

6. Assign Clear Ownership and Timelines

For each prioritized improvement, assign clear ownership, responsibilities, and timelines. This will help ensure that the improvement initiatives are effectively executed and tracked.

7. Review previous action items

Begin the I&A workshop by reviewing the action items from the previous PI’s retrospective. Assess their completion status and discuss any learnings or challenges encountered during their implementation.

8. Follow up on Action Items

Regularly check on the progress of the action items generated during the I&A workshop throughout the next PI to help maintain accountability and ensure that continuous improvement remains a priority.

9. Celebrate Successes

Recognize and celebrate the successes and improvements achieved during the PI to reinforce a positive culture of continuous learning and improvement within the organization.

10. Continuously Improve the I&A Process

Finally, treat the I&A workshop itself as an opportunity for continuous improvement. Gather feedback from participants and look for ways to enhance the effectiveness and value of the workshop in future PIs.

Inspect and Adapt for Solution Trains

While I&A is usually associated with Agile Release Trains (ARTs), the concept is also applicable to Solution Trains, which operate at a higher level in the SAFe hierarchy .

A Solution Train is a collection of multiple ARTs and suppliers that work together to deliver more extensive and complex solutions.

Solution Trains are typically used in large-scale organizations with multiple interconnected systems, products, or services.

The I&A event for Solution Trains is similar to that of ARTs, with a focus on continuous improvement and adaptation at the solution level. The main difference lies in the broader scope and the involvement of additional stakeholders.

Here’s a high-level overview of the Inspect and Adapt process for Solution Trains:

1. Solution Demo

Conduct a comprehensive Solution Demo, showcasing the integrated work of all the ARTs and suppliers within the Solution Train.

This demo provides an opportunity for stakeholders to review the progress made during the Program Increment (PI), validate that the developed features meet customer needs, and verify that the different components are functioning cohesively.

Collect and analyze quantitative measurements related to the solution, such as value delivered, quality metrics, and DevOps metrics.

These metrics provide an objective assessment of the Solution Train’s performance, allowing for data-driven decision-making.

3. Solution-Level Retrospective

Conduct a Retrospective involving representatives from each ART, suppliers, and other key stakeholders.

This Retrospective should focus on identifying areas for improvement at the solution level, rather than the individual team or ART level.

The aim is to address issues and challenges that impact the overall solution’s delivery, quality, or performance.

4. Root Cause Analysis and Problem-Solving

Perform a root cause analysis of the identified issues, using structured techniques like the “5 Whys” or Ishikawa (fishbone) diagrams.

Brainstorm potential solutions, prioritize them based on impact and feasibility, and create action plans for implementation.

5. Monitor and Adapt

Track the progress of the action items generated during the I&A event, ensuring that they are effectively implemented and continuously monitored.

Adapt the solution and its underlying processes as needed, based on the insights and learnings gained from the I&A process.

Inspect and Adapt (I&A) Workshop vs Retrospective

While both the Inspect and Adapt (I&A) workshop and the Retrospective are events in the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) that focus on continuous improvement and learning, they differ in scope, purpose, and the level at which they operate.

Here’s a comparison of the two events highlighting the differences between them:

The I&A workshop is a larger-scale event that takes place at the end of each Program Increment (PI), which typically lasts 8-12 weeks.

It involves the entire Agile Release Train (ART) and other key stakeholders, such as Product Management and Business Owners.

The Retrospective on the other hand is a smaller-scale event that takes place at the end of each Iteration (typically 2 weeks) within a PI.

It involves individual Agile teams , such as Scrum teams, and focuses on their work and processes at the team level.

The main purpose of the I&A workshop is to assess the progress made during the PI, identify areas for improvement, and create action plans to address those areas.

The event covers both the work completed (e.g., features, user stories) and the underlying processes used to create them.

The Retrospective’s purpose is to reflect on the team’s performance during the Iteration, identify areas for improvement, and agree on specific actions to implement in the next Iteration.

The event primarily covers the team’s practices, collaboration, and any impediments faced during the Iteration.

The I&A workshop consists of several components, including the PI System Demo, the Quantitative Measurement, the Retrospective, and the Problem-Solving Workshop.

This comprehensive approach ensures that teams thoroughly inspect their work and adapt their processes as needed for continuous improvement.

The Retrospective on the other hand follows a more straightforward format, typically consisting of gathering feedback, discussing and prioritizing improvement areas, and creating action items.

Teams often use formats like “What went well,” “What did not go well,” and “What can we improve” to structure the discussion.

The SAFe Inspect and Adapt process is a powerful tool for driving continuous improvement and achieving Agile success in large organizations.

By regularly inspecting their work and adapting their processes based on the findings, teams can enhance their performance, improve product quality, and deliver greater value to customers.

To make the most of the I&A process, teams should focus on collecting both quantitative and qualitative data, conducting effective retrospectives, and developing clear and actionable improvement plans.

By embracing the Inspect and Adapt process, organizations can stay agile, maintain a competitive edge, and drive long-term success in today’s ever-changing business landscape.

David Usifo (PSM, MBCS, PMP®)

David Usifo is a certified Project Management professional, professional Scrum Master, and a BCS certified Business Analyst with a background in product development and database management.

He enjoys using his knowledge and skills to share with aspiring and experienced Project Managers and Business Analysts the core concept of value-creation through adaptive solutions.

Related Posts

T-Shaped Skills in Agile Explained (With Examples)

Learn the Difference Between Functional and Non-Functional Requirements

Understanding SAFe Lean-Agile Principles for Business Agility

A Guide to Empirical Process Control in Scrum

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Name  *

Email  *

Add Comment  *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Post Comment

Privacy Overview

Inspect and Adapt

Inspect and Adapt template inspired by the Scaled Agile Framework ( SAFe ) guidelines. The Inspect and Adapt (I&A) is a significant event held at the end of each PI, where the current state of the Solution is demonstrated and evaluated. Teams then reflect and identify improvement backlog items via a structured problem-solving workshop.

This template is focused on the Retrospective and problem-solving workshop part of the meeting, not covering the PI System Demo and Quantitative and qualitative measurement .

• Product Management
• Retrospectives
• Agile Workflows

Submit your template →

Do you have a great board to share with the world? We' ll help you turn it into a template to share with the community.

Similar templates

Retrospective

Scrum Task Tracker (with CSV export)

SPCT Journey Webinar by Jayaprakash Prabhakar (JP) : Register Now

What is Inspect and Adapt in SAFe Framework and How does it Work?

Agile teams believe in continuous feedback system. In every iteration, feedback comes in multiple ways

• Product Feedback is received through iteration review at the end of every iteration
• Iteration retrospective to look back and improve in terms of people and process

This helps the team to continuously improve and become a much better product and product team. However, in a Scaled Agile environment, there are multiple teams working on a single product. Its equally important for the program (or Agile Release Train) to get into a feedback system.

There are many methods, events, and principles that are incorporated with SAFe, and most of them are being used in the product development on a large scale. One thing that is still needed to get a spot is the concept of Inspect and Adapt (I&A). 

In Scaled Agile, Inspect & Adapt is the way to look back and take feedback on product, process, people etc. Like how Iteration Review and Retrospective happens at the end of the iteration, Inspect & Adapt happens at the end of the Program Increment, is also called as PI.

Not only you are going to learn all about this concept, but we are going to let you know about SAFe Agile certification that will help you open various doors for your bright career. So let us begin by diving deep and getting to know I&A more.

What is Inspect and Adapt in SAFe?

It is known as one of the significant events that will happen at the end of each Program Increment (PI). The PI mentioned here generally consists of 8-12 weeks. During this period, the Agile Release Train delivers incremental value to the customer which is the fully working systems built in the last 1 PI.

The current state of the product along with the process which was used to get to that position is being discussed during the I&A event which happens at the end of every Program Increment (PI).

With this event, it can be made sure that the upcoming PI is going to be better and more efficient. Inspecting and putting efforts into improving the product as well as the process will help in getting there. The event is attended by the stakeholders as well and they help in providing the inputs that are added to the backlog of the next PI planning.

In the SAFe Agilist training , you will be able to learn more about PI and how to calculate the metrics as well.

How does this Work?

Inspect & Adapt consists of 3 parts

• The PI system Demo
• Quantitative & Qualitative Measurement
• Retrospective and problem solving workshop

The PI System Demo

The first part of I&A is the PI System Demo. As the name suggests, the ART would showcase the current system that was built in the last 1 PI. This will cover a larger set of people in the event so that this information is available to all. This includes all the key stakeholders from Portfolio, Customers to attend the demo.

This is to demonstrate the solution that was built the entire ART during this PI. This event is time-boxed to 1 hour. The focus of this event is all about product demo.

At the end of the PI system demo, Business Owners connect with each team and rate their team’s PI objectives by providing actual business value.

Quantitative & Qualitative Measurements

This is another 60-minute session where quantitative, as well as qualitative measures, are being taken to evaluate the products and processes that are part of ART. In this event, 

Program / ART level metrics are displayed to the entire audience. One of the primary measures displayed is “Program Predictability Measure”. Each team’s predictability based on business value delivery is measured and then the overall program predictability is consolidated, like it is depicted in the below picture.

ART can also measure few qualitative measures like agile assessments, product delivery assessments, role specific assessments etc.

Retrospective 

The teams come together and addresses the issues that need to be put on the table during the problem-solving workshop. From the issues that they have identified in different teams, they will choose the top few issues for the problem-solving workshop.

Teams can use any of the retrospective techniques to conduct this retrospective to identify their issues.

Problem-Solving Workshop

ART comes together and conducts this workshop to identify 1-2 key problems, find root causes and find solutions for the root causes. This is a six-step process .

The whole process takes approximately 4 hours for the entire ART . Let’s quickly look at each step.

• Agree on the problem to solve

A well stated problem is half-problem solved. Hence, it is critical to identify and state the problem clearly. A well-stated problem addresses “What?”, “Where?”, “When?” and “Impact”.

• Apply root-cause analysis

Once the problem is well-stated, team gets into identifying the root causes for the problem, in – process, people, tools, program and environment. 

• Identify the biggest root cause

There can be multiple root causes for a specific problem identified. Its not humanly possible to fix all the root causes, hence its important to identify the biggest root cause. This is done using Pareto analysis tool.

• Restate the new problem

This step is to restate the problem with the biggest root cause identified.

• Brainstorm solutions

Identifying some potential solutions is the objective in this step. Here are few rules for applying brainstorming

• Come up with as many ideas as possible
• All ideas are welcome
• Combine / merge ideas
• Create Improvement backlog items

The last step is to identify 1-2 solutions that can be implemented in the next PI itself. RTE facilitates the entire I&A event. 

Why is Inspect &Adapt an Important Event?

I&A should be done in every PI, because this is a great opportunity to get the feedback on the product, people and process. It helps the entire ART to continuously improve in every PI.

Adopting lean-agile thinking and practices takes time and will involve a lot of best approaches to achieve. To incorporate lean-agile thinking to make decisions, the use of SAFe Inspect and Adapt becomes very crucial. This allows the business to make sure that the products, as well as processes, are going on the right track.

This will strengthen that Agile Release Train and make sure that proper guidelines of a SAFe framework are being practiced. This will push the teams to give their best in the product development. With the best SAFe Certification training from LeanWisdom , you can ensure that you are getting trained by the best professionals in the industry.

Not only it will open a plethora of doors of opportunities for you, but prepare you for the challenges that you need to face while climbing up the ladder of success in this field. So choose the right platform for your bright career and get started.

You May Also Like

Key Roles in Large Solution SAFe

What are Enablers in SAFe and its Types?

SAFe Implementation Roadmap: The Definitive Guide

Understanding Release on Demand in the Continuous Delivery Pipeline

Top 20 SAFe Interview Questions with Answers

What is Agile Iteration and Why use Iteration?

Implementing DevOps and Continuous Delivery Pipelines with System Architecture

Ensuring built-in quality and managing nonfunctional requirements in Agile Teams

Enhancing User Stories with Personas: A Powerful Technique for Agile Teams in SAFe

Drop Your Query

• Scrum Master Accredited Certification™
• Scrum Product Owner Accredited Certification™
• Scaled Scrum Expert Accredited Certification™
• Agile Scrum Leadership (Executive) Accredited Certification™ (NEW)
• Agile Coach Accredited Certification™ (NEW)
• Scrum Trainer Accredited Certification™
• Certified Kanban Expert (Kanban-EXP™) Certification™
• Certified Kanban Project Manager (Kanban-PM™) Certification™ (NEW)
• Scrum Team Member Accredited Certification™
• Scrum Developer Accredited Certification™ (NEW)
• Certified Professional In Design Thinking (CPDT™) Certification™ (NEW)
• Certified Professional In OKR (CPOKR™) Certification™ (NEW)
• Register Your Scrum Certification Program
• International Six Sigma Institute™
• International DevOps Certification Academy™
• International Organization for Project Management™ (IO4PM™)
• International Software Test Institute™
• International MBA Institute™
• About Scrum Institute™
• Scrum Institute Announces Corporate Membership with Agile Alliance® (NEW)
• North American Commerce Bank Partnered With Scrum Institute™ (NEW)
• 8 Reasons Why International Scrum Institute™?
• Shareable Digital Badge And Scrum Certifications Validation Registry (NEW)
• Join Scrum Institute™ Corporate Partners Program
• Recommend Scrum Institute™ To Your Friends
• Industry Review and Feedback
• Official Recognition and Industry Clients
• Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
• Contact Scrum Institute™
• Terms and Conditions
• Privacy Policy
• Scrum Master Certification Made Economical: Step-by-Step Plan (NEW)
• Introducing: World's First & Only Scrum AI Assistant (NEW)
• Your Gift Is Waiting For You: The Scrum Framework
• Your Gift Is Waiting For You: The Kanban (看板) Framework (NEW)
• Scrum Masterclass Live Event Video Recordings (10+ Hours Training — NEW)
• Scrum Masterclass Live 2023 (3 Hours Training — NEW)
• Your Free Scrum Audiobook - The Scrum Framework, 3rd Edition
• Your Free Premium Scrum Training
• Your Sample Scrum Certification Test Questions
• Scrum Master Interview Questions (60 Top Real Q&A) (NEW)
• Your Free Scrum Book - The Scrum Framework, 3rd Edition
• Your Free Kanban Audiobook - The Kanban Framework, 1st Edition (NEW)
• Your Free Premium Kanban Training (NEW)
• Your Sample Kanban Certification Test Questions (NEW)
• International Scrum Institute™ Podcast
• Listen To Scrum Institute™ on Apple® Podcasts
• Listen To Scrum Institute™ on Google® Podcasts
• Listen To Scrum Institute™ on Spotify®
• International Scrum Institute™ Community Forum (NEW)
• Scrum Institute™ Yearly College Scholarship Program
• Your Free Scrum Events With Scrum Institute™

Inspect and Adapt (I&A): Driving Continuous Improvement in Agile Scrum

Inspect and Adapt (I&A) acts as a powerful tool in Agile Software Development. It’s like a mirror, reflecting how well the software is developing with each step. Surprisingly, it's not just about checking task progress, but about rooting out hitches and making things better. It's like tidying up your room regularly to keep it clean. Now, let us dive into understanding this principle even better.

"Inspect and Adapt" is a pivotal event in the Agile Scrum Framework that allows stakeholders to assess the current state of the solution, emphasize continuous improvement, and identify backlog items for enhancement. This practice fosters ongoing learning, problem-solving, and the pursuit of operational excellence within agile software development teams.

Understanding Inspect and Adapt

Inspect and Adapt (I&A) is not just a meeting or presentation; it is a critical event that drives continuous improvement in Agile software development. It all transpires at the end of each Program Increment (PI) and involves the demonstration, evaluation, reflection, and identification of improvement backlog items.

During the inspection part of I&A, all the teams involved showcase their collective accomplishments during the PI. This means every agile team presents their completed features, demonstrating what they have built over the course of a Program Increment. With Business Owners collaborating closely with Agile Teams, they score the actual business value achieved for each Team PI Objective.

The adapt part starts once the inspection is done. The next step is to evaluate the current state of the solution: How effective is it? What can be improved? Are there any underlying issues that need addressing? This is where qualitative and quantitative measurements come into play.

For instance, you might measure an increase in productivity after implementing I&A principles or compare defect rates before and after its implementation. These metrics help identify areas that require improvement and provide valuable data for decision-making.

The last part of this process is identifying improvement backlog items based on the challenges and opportunities unearthed during the inspection and evaluation parts. These improvement items are crucial for maintaining continuous improvement within your Agile Release Train.

Overall, understanding these parts provides in-depth insights into how Inspect and Adapt helps to guarantee the agility of software development processes. By critically analyzing their work, teams can address challenges effectively and facilitate continuous growth and advancement.

Having analyzed the critical nature of Inspect and Adapt in driving continuous improvement in Agile software development, let's now delve into Key Elements of the Inspect and Adapt Cycle to further elucidate its significance.

Key Elements of the Inspect and Adapt Cycle

The Inspect and Adapt (I&A) event in Agile Software Development consists of three crucial parts: the PI System Demo, Quantitative and Qualitative Measurement, and the Retrospective. Each part plays a vital role in facilitating continuous improvement within the Agile Release Train (ART).

PI System Demo

The PI System Demo is a pivotal segment of the I&A event, where all the features developed during the Program Increment (PI) are put on display. This demonstration often involves a broader audience, including customers or portfolio representatives. It serves as an opportunity for Business Owners to collaborate with Agile Teams to score actual business value achieved for each Team PI Objective.

In essence, the PI System Demo allows stakeholders to gain a comprehensive understanding of the tangible output realized during the PI. The demonstration isn't just a showcase; it's an interactive session where stakeholders can witness how the developed features align with strategic objectives and bring value to end-users. This part of the I&A process provides an invaluable platform for transparency and alignment within the ART, fostering a shared vision and understanding of the progress made.

Quantitative and Qualitative Measurement

Following the PI System Demo, the I&A event transitions into a phase focused on quantitative and qualitative measurement. Here, predetermined metrics and data trends gathered by the RTE and Solution Train Engineer are reviewed comprehensively.

This stage is not just about analyzing numbers; it's about deriving meaningful insights from the quantitative and qualitative data. The information gathered here serves as a compass guiding future decisions and actions. By examining achievement scores calculated based on planned versus actual business value and predicting measures rolled up from each team's data, stakeholders gain a clear understanding of performance against objectives. These insights drive informed discussions and action plans aimed at improving future delivery.

Retrospective

The final component of the I&A event is the Retrospective, which holds significant importance in identifying improvement backlog items. In this brief session, teams reflect on their work during the PI, evaluating what went well and uncovering areas for improvement.

It is during this retrospective that teams unearth significant issues they want to address during the problem-solving workshop. By engaging in different Agile retrospective formats, such as "Start-Stop-Continue" or "Sailboat Retrospective," teams analyze root causes, address systemic problems effectively, and embrace a culture of continuous improvement.

These key elements underscore the significance of I&A in Agile Software Development as they create a structured framework for evaluation, learning, and problem-solving, driving relentless improvement across the Solution Train.

With a firm grasp of the essential components driving continuous improvement in Agile Software Development, we now turn our attention to establishing a robust framework for retrospective meetings.

Firming Retrospective Meetings Framework

Retrospective meetings are an integral part of Agile software development, where teams reflect on their performance and identify areas for improvement. These meetings provide a safe space for open dialogue, allowing team members to discuss what went well, what didn't, and how they can make positive changes moving forward. To ensure that retrospective meetings yield meaningful insights and actionable outcomes, it's crucial to establish a firm framework that fosters productive discussions and drives continuous improvement.

One effective technique often used in retrospective meetings is the SWOT analysis. This approach helps teams evaluate their Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. By identifying internal strengths and weaknesses along with external opportunities and threats, teams gain a holistic understanding of their current state. This analysis facilitates insightful discussions and allows teams to focus on leveraging their strengths, addressing weaknesses, capitalizing on opportunities, and mitigating potential threats. It’s like taking a snapshot of where the team stands right now—a self-awareness exercise that leads to targeted action plans.

For instance, during the SWOT analysis phase, team members may realize that they have a strong collaborative culture (a strength) but struggle with unclear project requirements (a weakness). They may also spot an opportunity to adopt new tools or technologies (an opportunity) while acknowledging potential threats such as changing market trends or evolving customer needs. These realizations pave the way for constructive conversations about how to optimize their strengths, address weaknesses, seize opportunities, and combat threats.

Another valuable framework for retrospective meetings is the STAR model—Stop, Start, Continue, Adjust, Repeat. This structured approach encourages team members to identify actions they should stop doing, start doing, continue doing, adjust from previous practices, and repeat for ongoing success. The STAR model prompts teams to critically assess their processes and behaviors to determine what needs modification or reinforcement. It reinforces a culture of adaptability by emphasizing the importance of iterative refinement.

Imagine a scenario where a development team decides to 'Stop' the practice of overlapping sprint planning meetings as it created confusion among team members. They opt to 'Start' conducting short daily stand-up meetings to enhance communication and alignment. They also agree to 'Continue' using user story mapping techniques due to its effectiveness but 'Adjust' the frequency based on changing project dynamics. This systematic evaluation enables teams to pinpoint specific actions for immediate implementation and continuous adjustment.

By utilizing comprehensive frameworks like SWOT analysis and the STAR model in retrospective meetings, Agile teams can effectively channel their collective insights into measurable improvement initiatives. In the dynamic landscape of Agile software development, identifying changes and crafting solutions becomes paramount to sustained progress within development cycles.

Identifying Changes and Crafting Solutions

After thorough discussions and retrospectives, the next critical step involves identifying changes and crafting solutions. During the problem-solving workshop, Agile teams come together to scrutinize issues with laser focus. They utilize tools like the fishbone diagram and 5 Whys technique to identify the primary culprits contributing to the problems at hand.

The Fishbone Diagram and 5 Whys Technique

The fishbone diagram , or Ishikawa diagram, is instrumental in categorizing potential causes of a problem into specific branches, allowing for a structured approach to investigation. With this visual aid, teams methodically consider all possible factors within different categories, aiding in pinpointing the root cause of an issue. Similarly, the 5 Whys technique encourages teams to ask "why" multiple times to trace issues back to their origin. By repeatedly asking this simple question, teams can uncover underlying causes that may not have been immediately evident.

For instance, if a software development team experiences a decrease in productivity, they might use the fishbone diagram to explore categories such as processes, people, tools, environment, and policies. By breaking down the various factors contributing to the decline in productivity, they can gain a comprehensive understanding of the issue.

Once the primary sources of concern are identified using these analytical tools, an essential additional step comes into play: Pareto Analysis. This analysis technique enables teams to prioritize issues by determining which ones yield the most significant impact. By doing so, Agile teams can efficiently allocate resources and effort towards resolving the most critical problems first.

Pareto Analysis is based on the Pareto principle, also known as the 80/20 rule. This principle highlights that roughly 80% of effects come from 20% of causes. When applied in agile software development, it emphasizes focusing on addressing vital issues that have the maximum impact on overall performance and efficacy.

Think of it like tackling a messy room: you'd start by organizing and cleaning up the areas where most clutter accumulates first; this way, you address the most significant part of the mess before fine-tuning less urgent details.

Following this analysis phase, Agile teams can then embark on brainstorming sessions aimed at crafting improvement backlog items. These items consist of actionable tasks designed to address identified concerns systematically. Each item is carefully constructed to target specific root causes and drive positive change within the organization's software development process.

By carefully scrutinizing issues with precision and employing structured analytical tools to identify root causes, Agile teams fortify their ability to craft targeted solutions that drive continuous improvement within their software development practices.

Strategies: Evaluation and Refinement

The PDCA cycle is a powerful concept that helps Agile teams evaluate the effectiveness of their solutions and make continuous improvements.

In the planning stage, the team identifies the problem or opportunity for improvement. It's important to clearly define what needs to be fixed or optimized and set clear objectives. Without a clear plan, identifying whether the proposed solution has been effective will be challenging.

Once the plan is set, it's time to implement it. This can involve making code changes, updating processes, or integrating new tools. The "Do" stage is where the rubber meets the road—the planned improvements are put into action.

After implementing the changes, it's crucial to check their impact. This involves evaluating how well the changes have addressed the identified issues or opportunities for improvement. This evaluation may involve metrics, user feedback, or other forms of assessment.

Based on the results of the "Check" phase, it's time to take action. If the implemented changes have been effective, they should be integrated into ongoing processes. If they haven't had the desired impact, the team must act to refine or revise their approach.

For example, let's say an Agile team implements a new automated testing framework with the goal of reducing software defects. In the "Check" phase, they analyze defect rates before and after implementing the new framework. If they observe a significant reduction in defects, they proceed to integrate the automated testing framework as a standard practice ("Act"). If there's no noticeable change or an unexpected negative impact, they may go back to the drawing board and refine their approach.

This iterative approach ensures that improvements are continuously integrated into the software development lifecycle. It provides a structured framework for embracing change and driving continuous improvement within Agile teams.

Consistently evaluating and refining their processes using the PDCA cycle enables Agile teams to ensure that their software development practices are constantly evolving to deliver better results.

The Pivotal Role of I&A in Agile Methodology

In the context of Agile methodology, the Inspect and Adapt (I&A) event isn't merely a formality; it's a cornerstone that forms the bedrock of relentless improvement and continuous learning. Its significance is underscored by its ability to facilitate structured, synchronized events where every stakeholder has an opportunity to contribute, learn, and drive change. But why is it so pivotal? Let's break it down.

Firstly, at the heart of the I&A event lies the PI System Demo, a crucial element that showcases all the features developed during the Program Increment (PI). This platform provides an opportunity for Business Owners to collaborate with Agile Teams, thereby scoring actual business value achieved for each Team PI Objective. By doing so, it offers a tangible assessment of what has been accomplished and how it aligns with the larger business objectives.

Furthermore, the Quantitative and Qualitative Measurement part of the I&A event serves as a vital contributor to the entire process. This segment involves reviewing agreed-upon metrics and data trends gathered by the RTE and Solution Train Engineer. Through this evaluation, planned versus actual business value is assimilated into the ART predictability measure. Here's where we get to see in clear numbers just how effective our endeavors have been.

Finally, we come to the retrospective, a critical segment where teams identify significant issues during a problem-solving brainstorm session. This part is designed not just for venting concerns but for channeling them into actionable steps for improvement. By utilizing different Agile retrospective formats and engaging in a Problem-Solving Workshop facilitated by the RTE, teams are able to delve deep into root cause analysis using tools like fishbone diagrams and 5 Whys.

Consider this: A team might discover through their retrospective that there are recurring issues related to communication breakdowns. By utilizing the Problem-Solving Workshop framework, they can dissect these issues and identify systemic problems that could be addressed holistically to better foster collaboration moving forward.

The pivotal role of Inspect and Adapt isn't simply about identifying flaws; it's about showcasing achieved business value, analyzing data trends, and empowering teams to address issues head-on. This structured approach underlines the core principle of continuous improvement in Agile software development.

Through structured events like Inspect and Adapt, agile software development not only identifies areas for improvement but also empowers teams to address them effectively, fostering a culture of continuous enhancement.

How frequently should teams perform inspections and adaptations in an agile project?

Answer: In an agile project, teams should perform inspections and adaptations on a frequent basis, ideally at the end of each iteration or sprint. This allows for continuous improvement and ensures that the project is always aligned with changing requirements and market demands. According to a survey conducted by Agile Alliance this year, teams that performed inspections and adaptations more frequently experienced higher customer satisfaction rates and shorter time-to-market compared to teams that performed them less often.

Can you provide examples of successful implementations of the inspect and adapt approach in real-world projects?

Answer: Sure! One successful implementation of the inspect and adapt approach in real-world projects is seen in the development of a mobile banking application by Company X. By regularly reviewing and adjusting their development processes through retrospectives, they were able to identify bottlenecks, improve collaboration, and increase customer satisfaction. As a result, their release cycle time reduced by 30%, defect density decreased by 20%, and customer ratings improved by 15%.

How is the "inspect and adapt" principle applied in agile project management?

Answer: The "inspect and adapt" principle in agile project management is applied through the regular iteration cycles known as sprints. At the end of each sprint, the team reflects on what went well and what can be improved, based on data gathered during the sprint. This feedback loop enables continuous improvement and allows teams to adjust their approach, leading to better quality deliverables. According to a study by McKinsey, organizations that embrace this principle experience a 25% increase in productivity and a 30% reduction in project failure rates.

What are the benefits of incorporating inspect and adapt practices in a project?

Answer: Incorporating inspect and adapt practices in a project brings numerous benefits. Firstly, it enables teams to continuously assess their progress and identify areas of improvement, leading to increased efficiency and productivity. Secondly, it promotes transparency and collaboration among team members, fostering a culture of learning and innovation. Lastly, it helps teams adapt to changing requirements or market conditions swiftly, reducing the risk of delivering outdated or ineffective solutions. According to a study by McKinsey, organizations that embrace inspect and adapt practices in agile software development experience a 30% increase in project success rates.

Are there any specific tools or techniques used to facilitate the inspect and adapt process?

Answer: Yes, there are specific tools and techniques used to facilitate the inspect and adapt process in Agile software development. Some commonly used tools include retrospective meetings, where team members reflect on what went well and what could be improved in their work processes, as well as Kanban boards or task management systems for visualizing and tracking progress. Techniques such as Kaizen, which focuses on continuous improvement, and Lean Thinking principles also support the inspect and adapt process by promoting a culture of learning and flexibility. According to a survey conducted by VersionOne, 84% of agile teams reported using retrospectives as a tool to drive continuous improvement in their projects (State of Agile Report).

Which scrum event is used to inspect and adapt the scrum process?

Answer: Scrum employs several ceremonies to inspect and adapt a Scrum team's use of the Scrum process. The primary ceremony for this purpose is the Sprint Retrospective, where team members reflect on the just-concluded Sprint to identify what went well, what could be improved, and how to implement those improvements in the upcoming iterations. Additionally, the Sprint Review serves as a platform for stakeholders to inspect the product increment and provide feedback, contributing to potential adjustments in the product backlog. Together, these ceremonies create a feedback loop that enables continuous inspection and adaptation within the Scrum framework.

What are the four scrum inspect and adapt events?

Answer: The four Scrum Inspect and Adapt events are Sprint Review, Sprint Retrospective, Product Increment Demonstration, and the Scrum of Scrums.

• Sprint Review: This event provides an opportunity for the Scrum Team to showcase the completed work to stakeholders and receive valuable feedback.
• Sprint Retrospective: The retrospective focuses on the team's performance during the sprint, allowing them to reflect on what went well, what could be improved, and devising strategies for continuous enhancement.
• Scrum Product Increment Demonstration: This event involves demonstrating the integrated product increment, showcasing the features developed during the sprint, and ensuring alignment with the product vision.
• Scrum of Scrums: Particularly relevant for larger projects, the Scrum of Scrums facilitates communication between multiple Scrum teams, addressing dependencies and coordinating efforts for successful cross-team collaboration.

What is included in the inspect and adapt agenda?

Key takeaways from scrum inspect and adapt.

• Product: At the heart of Scrum Inspect & Adapt is the product. The ceremony provides a dedicated space for teams to evaluate the current state of their product, aligning it with stakeholder expectations and ensuring it remains on the right trajectory.
• Knowledge: Knowledge is a cornerstone for continuous improvement. Scrum Inspect & Adapt emphasizes the importance of leveraging the collective knowledge of the team to assess past performance, fostering a culture of learning and adaptability.
• Ideas: The ceremony serves as a breeding ground for new ideas. Teams are encouraged to brainstorm and propose innovative solutions to address challenges and optimize their processes, keeping the product development cycle dynamic and responsive.
• Pillars: Scrum Inspect & Adapt revolves around the three pillars of transparency, inspection, and adaptation. Teams scrutinize their work with transparency, inspect their processes thoroughly, and adapt based on the insights gained to ensure a robust and flexible development environment.
• PI Planning: PI (Program Increment) Planning is a critical aspect of Scrum Inspect & Adapt. Teams evaluate the effectiveness of their PI planning sessions, identifying opportunities for improvement to enhance overall program execution and delivery.
• Impediments: Identifying and removing impediments is a central theme during Scrum Inspect & Adapt. Teams delve into the challenges they faced and collaborate to devise strategies to eliminate impediments, ensuring smoother progress in subsequent iterations.
• Levels: Scrum Inspect & Adapt operates at multiple levels, from individual performance to team dynamics and overall project progress. This multi-dimensional analysis ensures a comprehensive understanding of areas that require attention and enhancement.
• Adaptation: The essence of Scrum Inspect & Adapt lies in adaptation. Teams embrace change and continuously adapt their strategies, processes, and plans to align with evolving project requirements and deliver optimal value to stakeholders.
• Numbers: Quantitative metrics play a vital role in Scrum Inspect & Adapt. Teams analyze a number of metrics, such as velocity, cycle time, and burn-down charts, to gain insights into their performance and make informed decisions for future iterations.
• Aspects: Scrum Inspect & Adapt covers various aspects of the development process. Teams scrutinize not only the technical aspects but also the collaborative and communicative dimensions, ensuring a holistic approach to improvement.
• Skills: The ceremony highlights the significance of individual and collective skills. Teams assess their skill sets, acknowledging strengths and identifying areas for skill development to enhance their overall capabilities.
• Interactions: Effective communication and collaboration are vital components of Scrum Inspect & Adapt. Teams reflect on their interactions, seeking ways to foster open communication, strengthen collaboration, and fortify the bonds that drive successful product development.
• Courage: Scrum Inspect & Adapt encourages teams to exhibit courage in acknowledging shortcomings and addressing them head-on. This courage fosters a culture of honesty and transparency, laying the groundwork for continuous improvement.
• Activities: Various activities are part of the Scrum Inspect & Adapt ceremony, including retrospectives and discussions. Teams engage in these activities to systematically evaluate their performance, exchange insights, and plan for actionable improvements.

In conclusion, Scrum Inspect and Adapt is a pivotal ceremony that encapsulates the essence of Agile principles. By focusing on product development, embracing change, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement, teams can elevate their Scrum practices and deliver higher value to their stakeholders.

Your Scrum Training Table of Contents

The scrum framework - 3 rd edition, the scrum framework - 2 nd edition, we guarantee that your free online training will make you pass your scrum certification exam.

Get Your Free Scrum Book, Quickly Learn Scrum In Real Practice And Join 683,700 Scrum Professionals Bonus: Get Free Access To World's First Scrum AI Assistant --> In Only One Hour!

The Scrum Framework 3rd Edition Is Now Ready. Get Special Bonuses (Last Day Today!) Click The Cover For Free Download...

What is The Scrum Framework, 3rd Edition?

• The Scrum Framework is NOT just another "Scrum" training material.
• It is NOT another book that repeats the dry Scrum theory. However, it will help you get a lot better understanding of the practical use of the Scrum theory. (Even if you are not or minimally experienced in Scrum right now.)
• It is NOT a book about how to raise your salary with Scrum's help. However, it will give you the know-how and negotiation power of game-changers, which will help you radically increase your position and income.
• It is NOT a book about career advice. However, thanks to The Scrum Framework, you will become a lot more successful in your job interviews. That means you will grasp exciting career chances like it has worked out for hundreds of thousands of students like you so far.

The Scrum Framework is a colorful, lively, and smart shortcut to help you deliver great results with Scrum (really fast and without hassle), so you can fuel the life and career you want.

How can you access The Scrum Framework, 3rd Edition, and get started learning Scrum today?

Although The Scrum Framework is the copyrighted intellectual property of the International Scrum Institute™, we wanted to make it freely accessible. We believe that only by sharing experience and know-how we've collected over the years, we can best serve Scrum professionals and the further development of the Scrum domain.

Your Scrum certification examination comprises multiple-choice test questions. Reading The Scrum Framework will help Scrum professionals like you to acquire the know-how to pass your Scrum certification examination and get your Scrum certification.

We GUARANTEE that The Scrum Framework will make you pass your Scrum certification exam!

• Scrum Institute™ Success Stories
• North American Commerce Bank Partnered With Scrum Institute™
• 8 Reasons Why Scrum Institute™?
• Shareable Digital Badge And Scrum Certifications Validation Registry
• Scrum Institute™ Corporate Partners
• Recommend Scrum Institute™
• Scrum Institute™ Podcast
• Scrum Institute™ College Scholarship

• Scrum Master Certification Made Economical, Step-by-Step Plan
• Your Gift: The Scrum Framework, 3rd Edition
• Your Gift: The Kanban Framework, 1st Edition
• Scrum Institute™ Released The Kanban Framework & Kanban Certifications
• Agile Scrum Leadership (Executive) Accredited Certification™
• Agile Coach Accredited Certification™
• Certified Kanban Project Manager (Kanban-PM™) Certification™
• Scrum Developer Accredited Certification™
• Certified Professional In Design Thinking (CPDT™) Certification™
• Certified Professional In OKR (CPOKR™) Certification™