Intelligent strategy by DESIGN | ||
Stop light reports are a great way to report on the status of your project to your stakeholders and they also provide a quick reporting from my team members to me at each team meeting (enabling us to reduce the time we meet!).
Let’s define (overall) what each of the colors means:
Project is at risk to miss a scheduled completion date, may be over budget or out of scope. Immediate management action required. Project may be at risk if issues are not addressed. Attention required. Project is on track to meet scheduled dates |
Now, let’s look at an example:
|
|
|
|
| |
Project is 1 week behind due to difficulty in scheduling meetings with users to gather data on current applicant tracking system. Will make up 3 days by holding meetings with larger groups of users of system than initially planned. Can make up 2 days elsewhere on project. | |
Team lead pulled from project to help on another project. Expected to be gone from this project for only 2 weeks. If extends longer than 2 weeks, will have impact on schedule. |
In this example, there are two issues – a schedule issue and a resource issue. There is a plan for both to be addressed. Because there is a plan in place and there is confidence that the plan will be successful to address the issues, these are “amber” rather than “red.” However – let’s assume that we find out that we cannot hold meetings with larger groups of users (schedule issue in table above), in that case, we need to go back to holding meetings with smaller groups and will not be able to make up the 3 days unless we can make those days up elsewhere. Assuming we cannot, this becomes “red.”
Now here is where I frequently see issues with stop light reports in use by many of my clients. Frequently, the client has not defined the parameters for the stop light report. For example, at one pharmaceutical client, a multi-million dollar project appeared to be moving along nicely until a review of the project overall showed that the team members had a different perception of what it meant for a task to be amber or red than the project manager had. For example, for the project manager, a task went to red when it was 1 week overdue; for the team member, that same task would go to red when it was 4 weeks overdue (the team member was confident he could make up the time.) At that same client, some team members were unconcerned about the budget and didn’t consider cost status at all when reporting on project status – assuming, as one team member noted, “…even if I go over budget, someone is likely to come under so it all balances out.” This led to the project manager reporting status to the project sponsors that was not accurate.
Fixing the problem
To be sure that status reports work effectively for your projects, and that everyone is looking at the status report and reporting on their tasks the same way, come to agreement on what red, amber and green means to you, your team and the key stakeholders/project sponsors.
Define parameters for red, amber and green : What does it mean if a project is in the “red?” Are you over budget by $ x or by x amount of days? Have you lost key resources or have they been reassigned? You need to define (in conjunction with your team and sponsors) what it means if a project is in the “red.” You might choose to set parameters for simple to more complex projects, based on strategic impact or based on number of resources. Same for “amber” projects – set parameters that are clear to everyone so that everyone is reporting the same way on their project tasks. Green is usually pretty clear cut!
Communicate those parameters . Once you have parameters set, communicate those parameters for reporting on project status to all stakeholders so when you update them on the project, there is no ambiguity about where the project stands. This enables for clearer communications and better management of your stakeholders overall.
Back to our client. Once we defined the parameters, communicated to all stakeholders and began reporting consistently across the board, we were able to ensure more consistency in how projects are managed and were better able to control projects across the board.
Don’t have parameters in place for your stop light reports? Take some time away from your projects today to work with your team and sponsors to put parameters in place for all projects moving forward. You’ll find your job as project manager a bit easier!
Comments are closed.
Communicating the status of the projects through the “red, amber and green” stop lights has been standard practice in many project status report meetings. It makes lot of sense during the end of the quarter stakeholder project meetings when individual statuses of critical project activities need to be shown.
From my experience and opinion, the amber light is always for “Challenges faced”, Delays or More support needed. Red light is when things have gone wrong or the activity is about to be shelved.
More importantly, the stop lights gives a quick glance for stakeholders on the health of the project. They can quickly narrow down on the “amber” and “red” lights for further discussion and support. Nice article. Cheers, Ramkumar
David – traffic light reporting enables for more effective and efficient reporting of EAC and NPV. By reporting through the use of a “traffic light” I do report on what the executive team and board wants to know, I just do it in a manner that is concise and understanding for all.
Traffic lights? There are only two things that are worth knowing about a project: estimated completion time, and estimated completion cost (EAC in EVM terms). Completion means delivery of the required capability. A board might also want to know the forecast NPV of the project. They might go a little further and want uncertainty bands around the forecasts (which should include for the assessed risk probabilities). Done.
The opinions expressed in this blog are my own and don’t represent the views of my current or former employers. These postings should be considered as guidance and “food for thought” but not professional advice. |
Copyright © 2009 - 2024 - All Rights Reserved - |
Start free trial
Key performance indicators (KPIs) provide projects with a lot of data. But to know whether those KPIs are on target requires more than just a gut feeling. You need a way to quickly and expertly evaluate whether project goals are being met. That’s what a RAG status does.
RAG status begins with understanding the acronym and how RAG status is used in project management. Then we’ll define RAG status tolerance and go into the various project professionals who use RAG status when evaluating a project. Finally, we’ll show what each of the RAG statuses means and how to respond to them to better understand a project.
An RAG status is like a KPI traffic light. The RAG stands for red, amber and green. Just like a traffic light, red is an alert, amber (or yellow) signals caution and green means all’s clear. Sometimes another couple of colors are added to the RAG status. That’s blue and gray. Blue indicates that the activity has been completed and gray means there’s an information gap that prevents the status from being correctly assessed.
RAG status is a way to quickly and visually communicate the status of various aspects of a project or multiple projects. By color-coding the project data, the progress and performance of the project or portfolio are more intuitive and delivered with greater efficiency. It’s a great technique for project managers to get a quick overview of the project, but also serves stakeholders, who want to know the big picture and aren’t interested in the details.
Using a RAG status facilitates understanding quickly and, in so doing, helps managers and stakeholders to target areas that require attention according to the color that it’s assigned. The red, amber or green also makes it easy to see what is on track and where actions are needed to get the areas in red up to speed.
Project management software can incorporate the RAG status. ProjectManager is award-winning project and portfolio management software with multiple ways to get a quick overview of the project’s performance and progress. We’ll get to the RAG status later, but first let’s review the real-time project and portfolio dashboard, which makes it fast and easy to gauge project KPIs such as time, cost, workload and more. The easy-to-read color graphs and charts automatically update in real time to provide a status report whenever a manager wants one, without the long and complicated setup required by lightweight alternative tools. Get started with ProjectManager today for free.
When using RAG status, it’s first important to know how to define each color so you can use it to track your projects . That is, what are the RAG status tolerance ranges? Usually, the RAG status tolerance follows this criteria.
This is only a guideline. Sometimes, the RAG status tolerance range needs to be adjusted to better fit the project metrics and KPIs being measured. For example, the amber status could be only five percent of the project target if the results are highly predictable or it’s critical to act quickly if the project is off track.
However, the amber status could be up to 20 percent if there’s not a lot of volume for the activity or the project manager isn’t as familiar with the activity. Just like a project plan , the RAG status tolerance is a moving target and not set in stone. Keep that in mind when coming up with the RAG status tolerance.
Get your free
Use this free Status Report Template for Excel to manage your projects better.
We’ve been referring to project managers and stakeholders as the main users of RAG statuses, but there are many people involved in the project who will want to use this technique. Those people will have some responsibility for managing the project or making decisions about the project. They are as follows.
The RAG status is used when making a status or portfolio report. It’s a way to orient oneself to the details to come. Users can add it to this free status report template for Excel , which captures details about the project over a specific period. This reporting tool helps project managers and keeps stakeholders informed on the progress of the project.
The free status report template captures everything needed to get a well-rounded project overview. There’s a project summary with key accomplishments, completed and planned work, milestones, deliverables and action items. The section on the project health goes over budget, schedule, quality and scope. There’s even a risk management overview.
Let’s view a RAG status example to better understand the RAG status and how it would look on a project report . Below is a portfolio report generated from ProjectManager. At the top, is a small chart with a list of projects.
The list of projects is the first of four columns. The other three columns indicate the project time, workload and cost. For each of the projects listed in the portfolio, there’s a RAG status, both indicated in color and a percentage.
Being at the top of the report, stakeholders can glance at the RAG status and get a quick understanding of whether the projects are on track in terms of their budget and schedule. Project managers also have this quick view of all the projects’ statuses, but can scroll further down to get more detailed information.
As noted, red in the RAG status is an alert that KPIs aren’t meeting the project target. It’s an alert that attention is required and must be responded to quickly or suffer going off track even worse. The issue could be that the project is over budget, is behind schedule, has scope issues or all three. In other words, the project is in trouble.
Don’t panic. Red status is a good thing in that the project manager and stakeholders are now aware of a problem and can start to address and resolve it. The immediate response is to dig into the data to find out what the issue is and then find out how to fix it, if possible.
Start with priority issues and be honest with the client. Nothing is served by hiding the fact that there’s an issue that must be promptly addressed. Create a recovery plan, which might mean more funding, extending the schedule or adding resources. However, the project may be beyond repair, in which case there’s no point in throwing time and money into it. Close the project down.
Amber is a RAG status that says the project needs attention. It’s not as dire as a red but still requires the project manager and team to investigate why the project isn’t meeting its target. The project can still be delivered within the currently approved tolerances. There might be costs exceeding the budget in certain areas, but it won’t negatively impact the overall budget. Or maybe there are delays, but they won’t affect the project’s deadline.
Amber status doesn’t necessarily mean taking immediate action. It’s more of a wait-and-see approach. The project sponsor should be more involved, checking in regularly and offering help as needed. The project manager will want to keep a close eye on the project status and stay in close contact with the project team , even more than usual, to catch any issues faster. The team should work on open issues to get the project back on track.
Green means that the project is moving forward according to the project plan. There are no concerns that the project manager needs to address. In other words, the project is under control . That means the project is meeting budget targets, is on track to deliver as scheduled and there aren’t issues that need to be resolved.
All is well with the project. The project manager will have to prove this to stakeholders, of course, by showing them reports and other evidence that the initiatives are going as planned. But don’t report the project as green unless it is. Any issues mean there’s an amber status. Nothing is gained by ignoring this.
RAG status is an effective way to measure a project against its plan, schedule and budget, including for program and portfolio managers . One of the main benefits outside of what has been related above is that the RAG status is a way to summarize all project reports to get a picture of whether the project, program or portfolio is on track.
Senior management often uses RAG status to quickly identify those projects that are in trouble and need more support to get them out of the red and into the green. But this only works when the RAG status tolerance has been set and the project manager is honest in assigning the proper status.
RAG status is part of the reporting process in project management. It’s simply a way to easily and quickly understand where a project should be at any point in the project’s life cycle. Therefore, it’s facilitated by project management software as one of its features is reporting on project metrics. ProjectManager is award-winning project and portfolio management software with powerful reporting capabilities that are easy to use and measure all aspects of the project.
Two of the most important project reports are the status report for managing one project or the portfolio report when managing multiple projects. Our reports can be created with a keystroke and the results filtered to show only what the project manager or stakeholders want to see. These reports , including variance, timesheets, workload and more, can also be easily shared with stakeholders to keep them informed. RAG status is embedded in the status and portfolio reports, including a blue status, which summarizes the report and helps to quickly capture whether the project is on track or in need of support.
One area that can show up in the RAG status is the project resources. Being able to manage those resources is going to help keep the project on track. Whether managing one or multiple projects, project managers can turn to real-time dashboards or the color-coded workload chart to make sure their resources are optimally utilized. The team page provides an overview of all projects and team members, including their tasks and the percentage complete they are. The workload chart makes it easy to see who is overallocated so the team’s workload can be balanced to keep them productive and working at capacity.
RAG status is a small part of the larger project management reporting process. To learn more about this essential tool to monitor and control the execution of a project across any number of diverse industries, follow the links below to some of the pieces written about status reports, project performance and more.
ProjectManager is online project and portfolio management software that connects teams whether they’re in the office or out in the field. They can share files, comment at the task level and update statuses on any device with our mobile app. Plus, everyone stays updated with email and in-app notifications. Get started with ProjectManager today for free.
Start planning your projects.
LeadershipThoughts
Project management can often seem like a tumultuous field, full of potential hurdles and unexpected pitfalls. Regardless of the size or scope of your latest project, there’s always risk involved. The crux of successful project management lies not in the lack of threats faced, but rather in how effectively these challenges are identified, managed, and resolved.
For this purpose, one effective tool that project managers use to identify and communicate issues promptly is the Red, Amber, and Green (RAG) status ratings. Often included in performance reports, this simple, visual system grants stakeholders an immediate understanding of project status and is an excellent way to track project performance.
The RAG system’s fundamental idea is each color’s universal association—red means stop, green means go, and amber means prepare to act.
Using the RAG status system, you can demonstrate both positive progress and highlight potential roadblocks. This dual-purpose approach is what makes this system a valuable integrative asset to your project management toolkit.
The application of the RAG statuses system lies within its simplicity. However, there’s a fine line to tread here—you risk oversimplification if not tentative. Here’s how to make the most of your RAG status reporting.
The first step to utilizing RAG statuses is to identify which traits of the project you’ll be applying them to. Some possible options include:
By selecting a few key points, you stop essential factors from getting lost in the mix. This refined focus allows the RAG system to truly shine.
Without clear definitions, the RAG system can quickly devolve into a minefield of ambiguity. When it comes to assigning a status, stay objective.
By providing clear definitions for each status, you sidestep unnecessary miscommunication and prevent the dilution of effectiveness.
Remember – the RAG status is not just a tool for you, but a communication enhancer with your senior management and stakeholders. To make sure everyone is on the same page, discuss your definitions, decide on them collectively, and stick to them.
The RAG status changes with the project’s progression. The amendment in status quickly flags shifting situations and provides vital timescales for response actions. Maintain a regular reporting cycle, updating your RAG status reporting accordingly enough time for management to respond effectively.
Rainbows may look pretty in the sky, but when it comes to project management, sticking to these three principal colors is the way to go. With an agreed and established RAG status system, you provide a strong, communicative spine to your project, ensuring that everyone involved knows exactly what’s happening, what to expect, and how to act.
In truth, using RAG effectively is not merely a snapshot of your project’s health but rather an overall framework for controlling your project’s destiny. So remember, be accurate, consistent, and ruthless with your RAG status – and ensure they play the pivotal role they should in delivering projects successfully!
Max Johnson is currently a Vice President at a Fortunate 100 company. He has also held multiple leadership positions at two startups previously. When he is not busy working, you can find him surfing at the beach or skiing in the mountains.
Leave a reply cancel reply.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.
IMAGES
COMMENTS
A project status report is a document that provides updates about the progress being made on a particular project. Project status reports can be very valuable in projects that involve several different individuals or teams, as they offer a central resource for all updates about a project's progress. Members of a team can also share project ...
Project - A temporary, goal-driven effort to create a unique output. A project has clearly defined phases, and its success is measured by whether it meets its stated objectives. Project accounting - In project management, project accounting deals with reporting on the financial status of projects. It measures financial performance and actual ...
Responding with the high-level status is the best response, but only if the status given is in a shared language that leadership understands. For the shared language, we recommend using green, red, and yellow. An example response for each health status: Green: If everything's on track, you can proudly state, "We're running green and ...
Exhibit 1 - Causality illustration. This means we as project managers must consider how changing Action A affects all the other actions in the system or project. Project managers can use Deming's Plan-Do-Check-Action (PDCA) Cycle as a tool to help better understand the impact of change on the project (Exhibit 2). Exhibit 2 - Deming's PDCA ...
Swanson, S. A. (2014). Anatomy of an effective status report. PM Network, 28 (6), 52-61. Writing a status report is easy. Writing one that stakeholders will actually read takes a bit more work. If creating an effective status report were as simple as filling in a template, every project could avoid communications gaps.
A project status report is a document that provides updates about the progress made on a particular project. Project status reports can be valuable in projects that involve several professionals or teams because they offer a central resource for all updates about a project's progress. Members of a team can also share project status reports with ...
A project status report is a document that describes the current status of a project. These reports are used by project managers to update stakeholders on the status of the project and to track expenses, hazards, time, and work. Project status reports are also useful for identifying problem areas and making necessary changes to the project plan.
A project status report is a concise, timely update on your project's progress. It provides essential high-level information, allowing team members and key stakeholders to grasp the project's current state quickly. These reports maintain alignment among all involved parties, highlighting what's on schedule, identifying obstacles, and outlining ...
Standard project status reports should include some or all of the following: A summary of project details, including program and project name, start and launch dates. A list of key team members, stakeholders, and project owners. The status date and cadence of the report (daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly) A summary of the project scope and budget.
A project status report is a short document or memo usually put together by the project manager to update and inform stakeholders (teammates, leadership team, or clients, for example) about the progress of a specific project. It can be delivered as a PDF, an email, a Slack message, or a more formal report created within a project management ...
Project status reports are taken repeatedly throughout every phase of the project's execution as a means to maintain your schedule and keep everyone on the same page. The status report for a project generally includes the following: The work that's been completed. The plan for what will follow. The summary of the project budget and schedule.
A project status report is a document that provides a point in time snapshot of where your project is at. It includes the business-critical efforts, progress, and risks associated with a project. While the format of project status reports may vary, typical components include: A project summary listing work completed. Forecasts for what comes next.
Basically, anywhere you need to tell people about status, you can use RAG. You could also break down the BRAG color scheme for each area of the project such as scope, quality, budget, risks and so on. This would require you to flag each individual area with a color (RAG indicators), like in the table below.
Let's explore the four most common types of status reports and their unique benefits. 1. Daily status reports. Daily status reports provide a granular view of a project's progress, ideal for fast-paced projects or those nearing critical milestones. These concise updates typically include: Tasks completed today.
5 Tips on how to write an effective project status report (+ templates) Tip #1: Get to know your audience. Tip #2: Summarize the information. Tip #3: Streamline the process by using project status report templates. Tip #4: Don't be afraid to ask for help. Tip #5: Verify before releasing. Project status report example.
Project Phase. Initiate: The projects purpose, scope (Charter) and stakeholders are being defined. Plan & Prepare: The project workplan is being created. Build and Manage: The project solution is being created or launched. Close & Sustain: Project deliverables are being finalized and handed off to the operational team.
When the project managers use traffic lights to convey the project status to stakeholders, the reporting format is known as " RAG status reporting .". RAG stands for red, amber, and green. These colors indicate the project status. A red light indicates problems, an amber traffic light indicates that the project is moving without any major ...
Red (trouble): Project is at risk to miss a scheduled completion date, may be over budget or out of scope. Immediate management action required. Amber (danger): Project may be at risk if issues are not addressed. Attention required. Green (all good): Project is on track to meet scheduled dates. Now, let's look at an example:
Here are the steps for how to write a project status report: 1. Create an outline. The first step to writing a project status report is creating an outline of the elements you plan to include in your status report. You can use a pre-made template as your report outline, or you can make your own by determining what sections are most important to ...
Benefits of Using RAG Status in Project Management. RAG status is an effective way to measure a project against its plan, schedule and budget, including for program and portfolio managers. One of the main benefits outside of what has been related above is that the RAG status is a way to summarize all project reports to get a picture of whether ...
2. Defining Each Status. Without clear definitions, the RAG system can quickly devolve into a minefield of ambiguity. When it comes to assigning a status, stay objective. Green: Everything is progressing without significant issues. Amber: There are potential issues that could affect the project if unaddressed.
The assignment status — property Assign-.pyAssignmentStatus — can record a user's judgment about an assignment on their worklist.. Don't confuse assignment status with work object status, a different property.. The following assignment values are often used: blank; Next — Signals to the user, manager, or others the intent or guidance that this assignment is expected to be processed next
Assignment status: (Enter organization and station to which currently assigned and duty station to which attached, if any.) 3. 3. If the Eligibility Staffing Committee determines that a student on Temporary Assignment status is not eligible for admission to the educational program, the student shall return to the student's local educational ...