Table 1
Table Showing the Six Themes and Two Subthemes Determined during Analysis of Free Text Answers
Theme
Subtheme
Interview as a Test
Intentional Testing
Situational Observation
Ambiguity of Fit
Need for Intentional Inclusion
Varying Commitment to DEIAA
Reflective Practices
Navigating Bureaucracy
The first section of the survey asked participants to indicate and reflect on the purpose of in-person candidate interviews, and a common theme uncovered was the idea that it was a test of the candidates, which echoed the recruitment literature. While many quotes may not specifically contain the term, the described intentions clearly fell into this theme.
“I also think that the in-person interview tests the interviewees’ ability to think on their feet, answer off-the-cuff-questions, and interact with many different groups of people, not just a core group of people within their potential future department. They need to work with many different people and be able to handle different groups, so this is a good test of that.”
Two important subthemes center on the fact that testing can be both intentionally created and done through situational observation. Intentional testing involves actions such as deciding not to send questions prior to the interview, designing a long day without sufficient breaks, and including activities designed to assess skills. This kind of testing is often a conscious approach to candidate interviews by the survey participants.
“Also, allows for a skills check regarding professional competencies.”
“You may also learn, specifically, about their ability to both respond under pressure, but also their stamina. What a candidate does and says at the end of the day can be informative about how they will respond to the pressures of our workplace.”
“In some respects, the presentations are to see how well the candidate read our website.”
Testing candidates based on situational observations was often described as getting a sense of the candidate beyond their application materials, or seeing their interpersonal skills in action. In this instance, survey participants may or may not be consciously aware that they are testing the candidate.
“The on-campus interview helped us ask more questions, get to know them better, see how they interact with current staff and other university stakeholders. I have seen candidates who were great on paper be rejected because they behaved disrespectfully in an in-person interview; likewise, not all excellent candidates represent themselves well on paper.”
“For me, there are things that need to take place in person that cannot be replicated virtually, such as interactions that happen over a meal, or seeing a person’s responses and interactions including body language and facial expressions.”
“I get to see how they teach, handle questions, and interact with potential colleagues over the course of a day’s in-person interviews.”
The authors believe most candidates understand that they are being tested by potential colleagues and managers through situational observation, and that not all testing is inherently negative or unnecessary. However, testing becomes negative and exclusionary when intentional testing situations and situational observation are undertaken in ways that set candidates up for failure rather than success. One survey participant described an example of how testing can have a negative impact on inclusion and diversity in libraries.
“I don’t think testing folks “on the fly” is useful for librarianship. This is more often than not a trap that negatively affects people with disabilities or varying language skills.”
A pervasive theme throughout the survey is the idea of a candidate’s “fit.” Unfortunately, as already explored in the literature, “fit” can be used for measuring all manner of characteristics, is rarely explicitly defined, and often reinforces whiteness in librarianship. The authors’ analysis reinforces these critiques, with most who support the idea of “fit” as part of the interview describing its use as evaluating some combination of interpersonal, communication, and behavioral characteristics of candidates.
“The way a candidate fits with the team is an essential aspect of the interview process.
Personality, affect, general ability to mesh with the team are key to success in my workplace.”
“Otherwise, I feel interviews are more about trying to determine ‘fit.’ We know from the candidate’s resume, vita & cover letter that the person has the right qualifications and ‘chops.’ Now, do we feel that we could work with them (and vice versa)?”
When discussing “fit,” the lack of defining and understanding the exact qualities being looked for and how they will be measured became apparent. The authors saw the idea of “fit” grow to encompass a myriad number of different qualities or skills of a candidate in a committee member’s mind, with no clear indication that they measure them individually, or do so in a way to reduce bias.
“I see some legitimate reasons to consider fit (and/or personality, depending how those are defined): determining whether a candidate’s particular skills and experiences fill an important gap on the team, identifying whether a candidate’s approach to the role or their work aligns with the organization’s expectations and needs, and identifying areas where a candidate’s behavior or statements might not align with organizational values, e.g., around equity, diversity and inclusion.”
During our evaluation of free text responses, a clear theme arose around the lack of intentionality of many search processes as described by the survey participants. There were several examples where committee members or chairs themselves described reactive, rather than proactive, scenarios and dismissed ownership of planning or change by claiming it was not their responsibility. This lack of intentionality leads to a lot of assumptions and uneven or unquestioned implementation of practices that may hurt DEIAA efforts.
“We have members of the hiring committee who require accommodations and thus are attuned [sic] to the needs of interviewees.”
“Much of these questions are more something that the chair of the search committee would likely be dealing with, and I have never served as a chair.”
“We do [provide pronouns] in our names on Zoom and many of us do in our email signatures when we communicate with the candidate. But it is not required of the committee or the candidate.”
Most concerning when there is a lack of intentionality around interview processes is that the candidate ends up not only having to prepare for a job interview, but also has to act as their own advocate to try and ensure they can perform at their best. There were many assumptions made that candidates would be comfortable asking for what they need from organizations that are historically racist, ableist, and exclusionary without some indication that it is safe to do so.
“I imagine that for most of these, candidates will request what they need; vegans will ask for appropriate food, and people who use different pronouns will state them. Or at least I would assume this.”
“I would generally say that our institution takes the stance that they will “happily” make accommodations when requested but that they see no need to explicitly ask candidates about accommodations.”
“But the onus is currently on the candidate to bring forward any accommodations they need, nothing about our process is proactive.”
If organizations and search committees do not take time to review their practices and be intentional about inclusion or what they are specifically looking for in a successful candidate, it leads to continued use of hidden agendas and implicit expectations, which ultimately reinforce whiteness.
“Agreed upon standards for attire—no. Assumed agreed upon standards—probably. I often don’t find out about these until I or someone else has failed the standard.”
“The process consists almost entirely of both explicit and implicit internal expectations that are never shared with the candidate, which leads to a hiring process that is highly arbitrary and that consistently fails to do anything to increase the diversity of new hires, particularly with regard to race and its accompany [sic] economic/class related hierarchies.”
The authors were unsurprised that a theme of varying states of commitment to DEIAA in both the education of committee members and in hiring practices emerged from the responses to the survey. There were statements that discussed inconsistent practices within committees and between different searches at an organization. There are also wide variations of practice across different organizations in hiring procedures. Some practices are variable due to the ability to exert personal preferences (e.g., sharing pronouns), some due to how hiring is practiced at different institutions (e.g., different standards for different types of positions, level of involvement of HR), and many are due to lack of training or intentional commitment (e.g., not showing candidates gender neutral restroom locations, taking stairs unless asked to take the elevator).
“Unsure how much information is provided [to candidates] but it seems not much as candidates are often surprised to find they are expected to walk around campus for a tour or to the dining locations, very little regard taken for physical accommodations [sic] for any space, and I realize how ableist [sic] these have been and I myself have contributed to [this] without being aware (oh let’s just take the stairs since the elevator is inconvenient) am much more aware now!”
“All gender restrooms are available but I don’t know if we are explicit about that option for all interviews.”
“A lot to think about here, I definitely need to do better on this front and our University needs to do better too.”
The lack of education on DEIAA and its implications for hiring committees was most apparent in discussion about accommodations for functional differences, both visible and invisible, and the idea of providing options for candidates to allow for an experience that better accommodates their needs. Many participants indicated a lack of understanding the intent of equitable experiences for candidates versus providing equal experiences.
“We don’t offer many options for the candidates, I think mostly because it creates too much variability between candidates for the same position (what we do for one, we have to do for all).”
“In order to ensure equitable interview experiences, all itineraries are kept as identical as possible.”
“I think at my last POW, since we were a public university, it would have been frowned on not to have all candidates have the same experience.…”
A theme the authors saw running through responses that aligns closely with the idea of intentionality in designing inclusive hiring processes is the need to incorporate reflective practices. There were several comments touching on the need to review current practices and reflect on their purpose.
“My institution keep [sic] saying they will develop practices but for the 10 years I have been here, there’s an attitude of ‘everyone KNOWS how to do interviews/hiring so we just proceed.’ I would have loved to have a discussion about what is the purpose of the CV screen, the phone interview, the in person interview, etc., on any of the hiring committees I [sic] have been a part of.”
When search processes are reflected upon and decisions become more intentional, the purpose of on-campus interviews seems to begin to shift toward mutual benefit and away from reinforcing the organization’s power over a candidate.
“Being on campus also allows the candidate to get a feel for what the campus is geographically like, its size, how many students are around, what the facilities are like. These kinds of intangible experiences are important, especially if there is a big move involved.”
“The in-person interview allows the candidate an opportunity to expound on his/her experience and how it relates to the position, allows the interviewers to observe reactions to questions and interactions between the candidate and other members of the university community, and provides the university and library a chance to showcase what they have to offer the candidate.”
“The on campus interview is a chance for the candidate to learn more about the culture and city of their potential new work environment.”
Instead of approaching interviews as a test of a candidate’s “fit” in the organization, intentional reflection can lead to more inclusive hiring practices that allow for a more equitable distribution of power in the process.
A persistent theme in the comments was the bureaucracy involved in hiring and how, in many instances, it is a hindrance to inclusive practices. This often appeared in statements regarding the amount of power HR had in hiring, or in their interpretation and communication of legal requirements. This also appeared in comments where responsibilities for creating welcoming processes were pushed onto the chair or HR department.
“At our institution, the chair of the search committee and the HR department ensures [sic] that the candidate’s needs are met.”
It appears that HR can often be a barrier to creating more inclusive and welcoming hiring processes due to their generally conservative stance. This appears in comments describing that all candidate experiences need to be the same and instances of a lack of appropriate or timely communication where candidate needs are concerned.
It is also apparent that many institutions expect candidates to pay for their own travel and hotel expenses and then request reimbursement from the institution. This places an undue burden on job candidates to cover the costs of interviewing. It is common for academic libraries to conduct national searches, which leads to a higher likelihood of having candidates for positions coming from outside the hiring institution’s immediate geographic area. The nature of these national searches may disadvantage candidates by making them responsible for large purchases like flights and hotel stays. Even when institutions reimburse candidates for these costs, candidates potentially carry these costs for months on credit cards that accrue interest. This burden could be multiplied if candidates are actively searching for a position and interviewing at more than one institution.
“Our university used to pay for candidate travel up front, but the policy changed a couple years ago and now candidates have to pay up front and get reimbursed. If I am the chair of a search committee I make sure I give candidates plenty of notice about this if they have an online interview, so they can plan accordingly.”
“I think in-purpose interviews are frequently used to exclude or other potential employees. The expectation of travel can be difficult on [sic] many, especially if the library is not paying for things ahead of time and operates on a reimbursement model. That combined with an in-person interview often leading to the disclosure of privileged information (e.g., disability status that cannot be hidden in person, pregnancy status), the experience gives those at the library doing the interviewing ample opportunities to judge based on non-job-related factors.”
The authors recognize that reimbursement may be a decision that is made at a state level, but it is an opportunity for advocacy that librarians should embrace in order to truly be welcoming to a diverse pool of candidates. The authors encourage HR employees, along with search committee members, to take training in diversity and equity issues in hiring to ensure that they are balancing compliance to legal requirements and regulations with best practices for more inclusive hiring. In particular, more training should be undertaken to more fully understand accommodation under the law, including barriers to receiving candidates versus accommodating specific requests of candidates and how bias and invisibility hinders inclusivity.
There were several major themes that emerged from this survey that are important to consider in order to create more inclusive academic librarian hiring processes at our institutions. Central to every theme is the need for intentionality in creating environments where candidates, particularly candidates from marginalized communities, feel welcome and set up for success during their interviews. It takes work from every individual to build their awareness and understanding of implicit and explicit bias and to examine every aspect of the hiring process and see where it is failing to allow every candidate the opportunity to succeed. It will take advocacy and consistent effort to change systems of bureaucracy and inertia found in established processes. This is important and critical work in order to design interviews where candidates do not have to take on the dual roles of proving their expertise and skills as well as advocating for their needs in order to perform to their best abilities.
The other themes and responses from this survey highlight issues and areas for research and improvement of practice. Incorporating reflective practices in the hiring process will be important in efforts to create intentional, positive changes. This process of reflection also appears to lead to a reevaluation of the purpose of on-campus interviews toward one that is a more mutual exchange and away from the idea of testing candidates. The belief that interviews are a test of the candidates was common, and appeared either through explicit testing of their skills through presentations and responses to interview questions or hidden testing through observation of their behavior, communication skills, or “fit.” Harm is created when the process is set up so that candidates do not know what they are being evaluated on, or when there are parts of the process that are intentionally included to be traps or stumbling areas for candidates.
This interview-as-test dynamic is most clearly seen when respondents were asked if candidates were sent interview questions ahead of time. There were several responses that indicated an unwillingness to do this because respondents valued the lack of preparation as a trap to ostensibly “test the candidate’s ability to think on their feet.” However, sending questions ahead of time does not preclude committees or individuals from asking additional questions of candidates to measure their ability to answer unknown questions on the spot. Providing questions in advance signals to the candidate that a) you recognize that not every candidate processes and responds to information in the same way, b) you value candidates who are reflective and take time to consider how they will respond before acting, and c) you are interested in setting candidates up for success during their interview.
Commitment to training all library staff on diversity and equity, including how implicit bias impacts hiring decisions, is critical. For instance, there were recurring responses to the survey that highlighted misconceptions about how equitable practices could be incorporated into interview processes without privileging one candidate over another. This misconception that equity is equivalent to providing the exact same experience for all candidates appeared in discussions of providing candidates with options for different aspects of the process. Several respondents suggested that candidates had to have the exact same experience for it to be “fair,” and that by offering candidates different options for which stakeholders they met with or which activities they took part in (e.g., campus tour, dinner with committee) would result in an inequitable process. In many cases, respondents seemed to be conflating equity with equality . Search committees are creating an equal process by providing the same array of options to candidates, whereas they are creating an equitable process by encouraging candidates to choose the option that allows them to fully engage in the process in a way that is most comfortable and supportive of their needs. For instance, giving all candidates the option to have dinner with the committee or on their own is building equity into the process by allowing candidates to make the choice that best fits their needs, and it ensures equality because all candidates will be offered the same options, even if they were to choose different options.
Examination of the systems and bureaucracy in place at academic institutions is also necessary in order to change hiring practices. This would likely include close examination of relevant by-laws, employee handbooks, and federal, state, and local laws. This cannot be undertaken by one or two people: it takes a coordinated and concerted effort by an organization to make recommendations for training, reinterpretation, and process changes. It will take committed advocacy to change institutional practices, particularly if it involves changing how money is used. This research uncovered that many institutions have moved from paying for candidate visits up-front to a reimbursement model, which is a barrier to increasing diversity as it places undue financial stress on candidates of all backgrounds.
The authors believe that intentional practices and reflection will also lead to either a reduction or an explicit understanding of interviewing for “fit.” By not explicitly defining how you evaluate the fit of a candidate, you will be reinforcing whiteness. Only through defining the qualities and characteristics that fit stands for and determining how to evaluate these characteristics with as little bias as possible will “fit” lose its power to exclude.
The specific findings from this research are not broadly generalizable as hiring practices vary across institutions, and each participant has particular attitudes and interpretations of practices and policies. The survey used in this study asked no demographic information, so it is not possible to distinguish between the hiring practices across different academic library types or for geographic differences.
This research contributes to the LIS profession by discovering areas of needed research in recruitment and hiring, particularly for DEIAA, and by providing a starting point for individual organizations to begin examining their own practices. Topics for further exploration include questions around the two distinct frames of the ethics of interviewing and the need for long-term and empirical studies investigating the impact of candidate interview experiences on their perceptions of the hiring institution, hiring statistics, and retention. The authors also see a critical need for better training and research into how to reduce ableist attitudes and practices in candidate interviews. A balance between disclosure of personal medical information and conscientious responsibility of search committees will be necessary to become proactive rather than reactive to the diverse needs of candidates, whether or not they fall under Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) protections.
There is a need to operationalize the word “fit” in academic librarian hiring. As a pervasive term and idea that varies widely from one individual to the next, it creates unwritten expectations for candidates, and causes search committees and future colleagues to look for characteristics and qualities in candidates that will help them assimilate into the dominant white culture of the hiring library. Recruiting for fit without an operational definition creates a level of subjectivity in the hiring process that disadvantages those who do not, or cannot, perform whiteness. Research or case studies into the process and impact of defining fit, or attempting to remove it entirely from hiring decisions, is necessary to move DEIAA in hiring forward.
Finally, the authors urge academic libraries to critically evaluate their entire interview process and determine what practices are truly necessary, and how those can be made to be as welcoming and inclusive as possible to ensure all candidates can perform at their best.
In this section, we ask you to reflect on the purpose of in-person or on-campus interviews.
What do you feel is the purpose of a face-to-face/on-campus interview? (check all that apply)
We would value your deeper thoughts about and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Purpose of Interviews” section:
In this section, we ask about your practices and thoughts on gathering and providing personal information pertinent to the candidates.
Do you ask candidates to provide their pronouns?
Do hiring committee members share their pronouns with candidates?
Is anyone on the hiring committee notified when candidates need ADA-specified accommodations?
Do you encourage candidates to request accommodations regardless of ADA-definitions?
What additional accommodations do you encourage candidates to request? (check all that apply)
We would value your deeper thoughts about and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Personal Information about Candidates” section:
In this section, we ask about your practices and thoughts as they relate to planning candidate itineraries, including the economic costs associated with searching.
My library does the following for candidates (check all that apply):
How long are your interviews?
We would value your deeper thoughts and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Itinerary Planning Practices” section:
In this section, we ask about practices your hiring committees use to reduce the cognitive load and mental stress candidates carry throughout the interview process.
My library incorporates the following stress and cognitive load reduction strategies into the interview process (check all that apply):
Does your library require candidates to give presentations during the interview day?
What types of presentations are candidates for librarian positions at your institution expected to give during the interview? (check all that apply)
We would value your deeper thoughts and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Stress & Cognitive Load Reduction Strategies” section:
In this section, we ask if your hiring committee(s) use strategies that have been shown to help reduce implicit bias in hiring decisions.
My library incorporates the following bias reduction strategies into the interview process (check all that apply):
We would value your deeper thoughts and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Bias Reduction Strategies” section:
In this section, we ask about your practices around scheduling and participation in meals during interview day(s).
Do candidates get a choice in the number of meals that are included in the interview?
Who typically participates in the meals? (check all that apply)
How are meal participants chosen? (check all that apply)
We would value your deeper thoughts and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Meals & Dietary Accommodation” section:
In this section, we ask you to describe any ways you regularly make the physical environment more accommodating to candidates—whether they have an ADA-recognized accessibility request or not.
My library incorporates the following strategies to address physical accessibility, regardless of any required ADA accommodations, in the interview process (i.e., these are always available or available on request without “proof” of need) (check all that apply):
We would value your deeper thoughts and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Physical Accommodations” section:
In this section, we ask for your practices and thoughts about intentional communication with candidates, and additional support you might provide for them.
Does your library have agreed upon internal expectations/ guidance for candidate attire during the interview day?
Does your library communicate attire expectations /guidance to candidates prior to on-campus interviews?
Does your library provide any guidance to or assistance for candidates who have limited access to standard interview attire?
My library does the following to communicate with and about the candidate during the interview process (check all that apply):
Do you request and review candidate references prior to their on-campus interview?
We would value your deeper thoughts about and experiences with the activities mentioned in this section. Please tell us about your reaction to the presented options, your institution’s practices, and your personal opinions regarding the “Communication with and about Candidates” section:
Do you have any other thoughts about creating a welcoming and inclusive on-campus interview process for academic librarians?
1. Kathy Rosa and Kelsey Henke, 2017 ALA Demographic Study (Chicago, IL: American Library Association, 2017), 1–2.
2. Arnold Brown and Edith Weiner, Supermanaging: How to Harness Change for PersonaI and Organizational Success (United Kingdom: McGraw-Hill, 1984), p. ix.
3. Dennis R. Defa, “Recruitment of Employees in Academic Libraries: Advice from the HR Perspective,” Library Leadership & Management 26, no. 3/4 (2012).
4. Kimberley Bugg, “Best Practices for Talent Acquisition in 21st-Century Academic Libraries,” Library Leadership & Management 29, no. 4 (2015).
5. Scottie Kapel, Elizabeth M. Skeene, and Whitney P. Jordan, “Nothing Happens unless First a Dream: Demystifying the Academic Library Job Search and Acing the Application Process” (paper presented at the 2018 Charleston Conference, Charleston, SC, November 5–9, 2018), https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/charleston/2018/upandcoming/2/ ; Angela R. Davis, “Searching for an Academic Librarian Job: Techniques to Maximize Success,” Pennsylvania Libraries: Research & Practice 3, no. 2 (2015): 136–43; Philip C. Howze, “New Librarians and Job Hunting: Patience is a Virtue,” College & Research Libraries News 62, no. 6 (2001): 596–634; Megan Hodge and Nicole Spoor, “Congratulations! You’ve Landed an Interview: What Do Hiring Committees Really Want,” New Library World 112, no. 3/4 (2012): 139–161; Suann Alexander, Jackie Dowdy, and Sharon Parente, “Demystifying the Academic Search Process, or Getting That Academic Librarian Position,” Tennessee Libraries 59, no. 2 (2009).
6. Sojourna Cunningham, Samantha Guss, and Jennifer Stout, “Challenging the ‘Good Fit’ Narrative: Creating Inclusive Recruitment Practices in Academic Libraries,” (paper presented at the Association of College & Research Libraries 2019 Conference, Cleveland, OH, April 10–13, 2019), https://alair.ala.org/bitstream/handle/11213/17632/ChallengingtheGoodFitNarrative.pdf
7. Cunningham, Guss, and Stout, “Challenging the ‘Good Fit’ Narrative,” 17.
8. Ibid.
9. Gregory K. Raschke, “Hiring and Recruitment Practices in Academic Libraries: Problems and Solutions,” portal: Libraries and the Academy 3, no. 1 (2003): 53–67.
10. Raschke, “Hiring and Recruitment Practices in Academic Libraries,” 64.
11. Ibid., 65.
12. Zhonghong Wang and Charles Guarria, “Unlocking the Mystery: What Academic Library Search Committees Look for in Filling Faculty Positions,” Technical Services Quarterly 27, no. 1 (2010): 66–86.
13. Wang and Guarria, “Unlocking the Mystery,” 73–76.
14. Tina P. Franks, Tina Budzise-Weaver, and Leslie J. Reynolds, “Unlocking Library Search Committees at ARL Public Universities: Techniques and Best Practices for Getting Hired,” Information and Learning Science 118, no. 5/6 (2017): 252–65.
15. Angela Galvan, “Soliciting Performance, Hiding Bias: Whiteness and Librarianship,” In the Library with the Lead Pipe , (2015): https://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2015/soliciting-performance-hiding-bias-whiteness-and-librarianship/ , para. 4.
16. Galvan, “Soliciting Performance, Hiding Bias,” para. 1.
17. April Hathcock, “White Librarianship in Blackface: Diversity Initiatives in LIS,” In the Library with the Lead Pipe, (2015): https://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2015/lis-diversity/ , para. 4.
18. Ronald E. Wheeler, Nancy P. Johnson, and Terrance K. Manion, “Choosing the Best Candidate: Best Practices in Academic Law Library Hiring,” Law Library Journal 100, no. 1 (2008): 117–35.
19. Karin Durán, Eric P. Garcia, and Mara L. Houdyshell, “From the Inside Out and the Outside In: The Academic Library Interview Process in a Tight Economy,” College & Research Libraries News 70, no. 4 (2009): 216–19.
20. Candice Benjes-Small, Eric Ackerman, and Gene Hyde, “Job Hunting: What Search Committees Want You to Know,” (paper presented at the Association of College & Research Libraries 2011 Conference, Philadelphia, PA, March 30–April 2, 2011), https://www.ala.org/acrl/sites/ala.org.acrl/files/content/conferences/confsandpreconfs/national/2011/papers/job_hunting.pdf , 247.
21. See Appendix A.
22. Virginia Braun and Victoria Clarke, “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology,” Qualitative Research in Psychology 3, no. 2 (2006): 77–101.
23. April Hathcock and Jennifer Vinopal, “Feminist Praxis in Library Leadership,” in Feminists among Us: Resistance and Advocacy in Library Leadership , eds. Shirley Lew and Baharak Yousefi (Sacramento, CA: Library Juice Press, 2017), 147–71.
* Kathryn (Katie) Houk is an Associate Professor and Undergraduate Medical Education Librarian at the University of Nevada Las Vegas’ School of Medicine Library, email: [email protected] ; Jordan Nielsen is an Associate Professor and Inclusion & Education Librarian in the James E. Walker Library at Middle Tennessee State University, email: [email protected] . ©2023 Katie Houk and Jordan Nielsen, Attribution-NonCommercial ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ ) CC BY-NC.
Contact ACRL for article usage statistics from 2010-April 2017.
2024 |
January: 94 |
February: 103 |
March: 111 |
April: 79 |
May: 80 |
June: 97 |
July: 80 |
August: 52 |
September: 0 |
2023 |
January: 0 |
February: 0 |
March: 0 |
April: 0 |
May: 0 |
June: 3 |
July: 1294 |
August: 465 |
September: 187 |
October: 94 |
November: 88 |
December: 118 |
© 2024 Association of College and Research Libraries , a division of the American Library Association
Print ISSN: 0010-0870 | Online ISSN: 2150-6701
ALA Privacy Policy
ISSN: 2150-6701
LibGig is your go-to resource for librarians, researchers and other knowledge and information management workers. It’s our specialty. As part of the LAC Group family, LibGig brings valuable insights and best practices to information center staffing and services.
LibGig was founded in 1986 as Library Associates, a library staffing agency. Our business has expanded to include multiple clients in an array of information and knowledge industries.
For managers or experienced hires capable of wearing many hats, LibGig recruiters will tap into a network of library and information center professionals with the seniority and capabilities you seek.
Brad Rogers [email protected]
The resources on this list were offered in the LJA Continuing Education course "Recruiting and Retaining Librarians from Underrepresented Minoritized Groups" with instructors Tarida Anantachai and Twanna Hodge in July, 2020.
LJA Profile: Tarida Anantachai is the Lead Librarian for the Learning Commons at the Syracuse University Libraries, where she also serves as liaison to her campus’ international student services center, English language institute, and multicultural affairs office. Tarida received her MS in library and information science from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Her research interests include diversity, equity, and inclusion, early career development and mentoring, and outreach programming. Tarida was an ALA Emerging Leader and is an alumna of the Minnesota Institute for Early Career Librarians.
LJA Profile: Twanna Hodge (she/her/hers) is the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Librarian at the University of Florida, George A. Smathers Libraries. She holds a BA in Humanities from the University of the Virgin Islands and an MLIS from the University of Washington. Her research interests are diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility issues and efforts in the LIS curriculum and workplace, library residencies and fellowships, cultural humility in librarianship, and the retention of minority library staff in librarianship. She is a 2013 Spectrum Scholar and 2018 ALA Emerging Leader.
We are happy to answer all your admission related enquiries. Fill out the form and we will be in touch with you shortly.
We acknowledge the receipt of your enquiry. Our team will get back to you shortly.
The Chartered Market Technician® (CMT) credential is the preeminent, global designation for practitioners of technical analysis. Awarded to those who demonstrate mastery of a core body of knowledge of investment risk in portfolio management settings:
The CMT designation develops deep knowledge in technical analysis and will directly impact the work of portfolio managers, hedge fund managers, investment advisors, RIAs, investment strategists, heads of research, and chief investment officers.
FREE This question is part of |
Doc | 11 Pages |
Doc | 14 Pages |
Video | 01:55 min |
Doc | 14 Pages |
Video | 01:55 min |
Doc | 5 Pages |
Doc | 12 Pages |
Doc | 11 Pages |
Directions: study the following information carefully and answer the question which follow:a research institute is recruiting a librarian to digitise its information resources among other duties. candidates must possess the following criteria. the candidate must -(i) be not less than 35 years and not exceed 40 years as on 01 .11 .2009.(ii) have a bachelor's degree in library and information science with 65 percent marks.(iii) have a ph.d. in library science.(iv) have post qualification experience of at least 4 years in a university library.however if the candidate fulfils the above mentioned criteria except -(, directions for questions: study the following information carefully and answer the questions which follow: a research institute is recruiting a librarian to digitise its information resources among other duties. candidates must possess the following criteria. the candidate must -(i) be not less than 35 years and not exceed 40 years as on 01 .11 .2009. (ii) have a bachelor's degree in library and information science with 65 percent marks. (iii) have a ph.d. in library science. (iv) have post qualification experience of at least 4 years in a university library. however if the candidate fulfils the above mentioned criteria except -(, directions: read the following passage carefully and answer the given question.the system of managing a companys interaction with current and future customers is called customer relationship management or crm. it makes use of modern technology to organise, automate and synchronise the following four areas; sales, marketing, customer service and technical support.crm is designed to track and measure marketing campaigns over a variety of networks. these systems can track customer analysis by customer clicks as well as sales. specifically, these systems are used in call centres, social media, direct mail, data storage files, banks and customer data queries. one unique aspect of this is that it can assist in formulating customer profiles.the goal of these systems is to track customers and their responses, record these responses and store them in databases and then mine this data for information that will improve customer relations. the crm system codifies the interactions between companies and their customers in order to maximise sales. they make use of analytics and key performance indicators to give users much information on where to focus their marketing and customer service to maximise revenues as well as to decrease idle and unproductive contact with customers. contact channels such as contact centres make use of crm software. the software helps to direct customers to the right agent or information channel (such as informational recordings or automated bill payment or appointment scheduling). one key feature of crm software is that it can be used to identify and reward loyal customers over a period of time, which can enhance customer relationships.one common function that crm software is used for is to synchronise suitable appointment dates, times and methods for customer contact. once the appointments are saved in the systems calendar, the information regarding the appointment can be easily retrieved. it can pull up information on specific information and then send an automated message as a reminder to the involved persons.because of modern technology, the environment often requires businesses to interact with each other via the web. because of this, the sweeny group defines crm as being all the tools, technologies and procedures that are required to manage, improve or facilitate sales, customer/technical support and all related interactions with customers, prospective customers and business partners throughout the entire venture. based on this definition, it is assumed that crm is involved in every business to business transaction.the general concept is that crm systems were created for customer-centric businesses, but they can also apply to business to business environments. in this sense, they are used to streamline and improve customer management conditions. both systems (business to customer, business to business) are not created equal and are different in application. this is because relationships between business to business take longer to come to fruition than the business to customer. with this in mind, all softwares used for crm must be personalised and delivered at individual levels.q.which of the following can be said about the current status of the usage of crm systems, directions: read the following passage carefully and answer the given question.the system of managing a companys interaction with current and future customers is called customer relationship management or crm. it makes use of modern technology to organise, automate and synchronise the following four areas; sales, marketing, customer service and technical support.crm is designed to track and measure marketing campaigns over a variety of networks. these systems can track customer analysis by customer clicks as well as sales. specifically, these systems are used in call centres, social media, direct mail, data storage files, banks and customer data queries. one unique aspect of this is that it can assist in formulating customer profiles.the goal of these systems is to track customers and their responses, record these responses and store them in databases and then mine this data for information that will improve customer relations. the crm system codifies the interactions between companies and their customers in order to maximise sales. they make use of analytics and key performance indicators to give users much information on where to focus their marketing and customer service to maximise revenues as well as to decrease idle and unproductive contact with customers. contact channels such as contact centres make use of crm software. the software helps to direct customers to the right agent or information channel (such as informational recordings or automated bill payment or appointment scheduling). one key feature of crm software is that it can be used to identify and reward loyal customers over a period of time, which can enhance customer relationships.one common function that crm software is used for is to synchronise suitable appointment dates, times and methods for customer contact. once the appointments are saved in the systems calendar, the information regarding the appointment can be easily retrieved. it can pull up information on specific information and then send an automated message as a reminder to the involved persons.because of modern technology, the environment often requires businesses to interact with each other via the web. because of this, the sweeny group defines crm as being all the tools, technologies and procedures that are required to manage, improve or facilitate sales, customer/technical support and all related interactions with customers, prospective customers and business partners throughout the entire venture. based on this definition, it is assumed that crm is involved in every business to business transaction.the general concept is that crm systems were created for customer-centric businesses, but they can also apply to business to business environments. in this sense, they are used to streamline and improve customer management conditions. both systems (business to customer, business to business) are not created equal and are different in application. this is because relationships between business to business take longer to come to fruition than the business to customer. with this in mind, all softwares used for crm must be personalised and delivered at individual levels.q.which of the following is possibly the most appropriate title for the passage, top courses for cat view all.
Top courses for cat.
Related content.
Doc | 14 Pages |
Video | 01:55 min |
Doc | 5 Pages |
Doc | 12 Pages |
Doc | 11 Pages |
Share your doubts
cation olution |
Join the 10M+ students on EduRev |
Create your account for free.
Unattempted tests, change country, practice & revise.
An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.
Here's how you know
Official websites use .gov A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS A lock ( Lock A locked padlock ) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.
Alternative traffic enforcement is an emerging crime and justice issue prompted by efforts of dozens of jurisdictions throughout the United States. In response to documented dangers and disparities, they seek to change how some traffic violations are handled. Specifically, these strategies try to increase public safety and reduce demands on officers by deprioritizing some traffic offenses and shifting enforcement responsibilities to alternative agencies or technologies. Most of these programs are in their infancy. Few have documented outcomes or formal evaluations to assess their effectiveness. As a result, there is a little information about the potential impact of recent initiatives on public and officer safety, disparities, and other important outcomes, which provides a fundamental research opportunity. The article first describes the issue and current state of U.S. alternative traffic enforcement strategies, highlighting challenges in measuring disparities. It then provides a summary of documented alternative traffic enforcement reforms, initiatives, and related research. The article closes with a description of future research opportunities.
Related topics, similar publications.
Wii invites applications from indian nationals for 08 contractual positions of research/project personnel under various research projects. (wii/advt. 3/rp–cell/august, 2024).
Plug-in: D ow nload Adobe Acrobat Reader
| |
Raman research institute.
Position | Librarian |
---|---|
Pay Level (As per 7th CPC) | Level-13 |
Vacancy | 01 |
Essential Qualifications | |
For Deputation | |
Upper Age Limit | 56 years as on last date of application |
Last date for submission of application: 14th October 2024
Method of Selection: Personal Interview
Applications can be sent in a sealed cover super-scribing the post applied for on the envelope to:
Administrative Officer Raman Research Institute C.V. Raman Avenue, Sadashivanagar, Bengaluru – 560080
Applications received after the last date will not be considered.
For further details, please refer to the Raman Research Institute Recruitment Notice .
MySarkariNaukri
Vacancy Circular No: 2/2023
Raman Research Institute (RRI) Librarian and Various Posts Recruitment 2023 Advertisement for the post of Librarian and Various Posts in Raman Research Institute (RRI). Candidates are advised to read the details, and eligibility criteria mentioned below for this vacancy. Candidates must check their eligibility i.e. educational qualification, age limit, experience and etc. The eligible candidates can submit their application directly before 4th January 20243. Candidates can check the latest Raman Research Institute (RRI) Recruitment 2023 Librarian and Various Posts Vacancy 2023 details and apply online at the www.rri.res.in/ recruitment 2023 page.
Number of Vacancy: 03 Posts
Educational Qualification: Candidates Should have Master’s Degree, Bachelor’s Degree from a recognized University. For more details, please refer to official notification.
Pay Scale: INR Level-13 /- Per Month
Age Limit: Maximum 56 Years.
Selection Procedure: please refer to official notification.
Application Fee: please refer to official notification.
Applications for this job are to be filled online. Please follow the link is given below to apply (or visit the original job details page): https://www.rri.res.in/careers/other-openings . (This Job Source is Employment News 4-10 November 2023, Page No.31)
Published on: 2nd November 2023
For more details, please refer to official notification at Download Official Notification
List of active jobs at Raman Research Institute. The other Related Jobs Raman Research Institute Recruitment Notification
Last Date for application: 14th October 2024
Job Location: Sadashivanagar, Bangalore
Pay Scale: INRLevel-13
List of old jobs.
Job Title / Posts | Last Date |
---|---|
03 Posts) Posts Sadashivanagar, Bangalore | |
12 Posts) Posts Sadashivanagar, Bangalore |
About raman research institute.
The Raman Research Institute was founded in 1948 by the Indian physicist and Nobel Laureate, Sir C V Raman, to continue his studies and basic research after he retired from the Indian Institute of Science. Sir C V Raman served as its director carrying on his personal research until his demise in 1970. It was funded personally by him and with donations from private sources.
In December 1934, the Government of Mysore gifted a plot of land in Bangalore to Professor Raman for the creation of a research institute. In the same year, the Indian Academy of Sciences was founded by Prof. Raman. Some years following the creation of the Raman Research Institute in 1948, Prof. Raman made a gift of various movable and immovable properties to the Academy for the use and benefit of the Raman Research Institute. After the Professor's demise in November 1970, the Academy created a public charitable trust: the Raman Research Institute Trust. The lands, buildings, deposits, securities, bank deposits, money, laboratories, instruments, and all other movable and immovable properties held by the Academy for the Raman Research Institute were transferred to the RRI Trust. The foremost function of the RRI Trust was to maintain, conduct and sustain the Raman Research Institute.
The Raman Research Institute is now an autonomous research institute engaged in research in basic sciences. In 1972, the RRI was restructured to become an aided autonomous research institute receiving funds from the Department of Science and Technology of the Government of India. A set of Regulations and Bye-Laws were framed for its administration and management. Today, the main areas of research at the Institute are Astronomy & Astrophysics, Light & Matter Physics, Soft Condensed Matter, and Theoretical Physics.
How many vacancies are there.
There are 3 vacancies in total. Librarian and Various Posts: 03 Posts,
The Payscale is as follows Librarian and Various Posts: INRLevel-13,
You can go through the offical document provided, and follow the instructions to apply online. Always follow the dates mentioned in the official PDF.
The selected candidate will be placed in Sadashivanagar, Bangalore
The last date to apply for Raman Research Institute Librarian and Various Posts: 03 Posts, is 4th January, 2024
Complete information regarding this job is given on this page. Link to official document is also provided. The candidates are adivsed to go through it thorouly before Apply Online. If the job interests you and you are eligible for Librarian and Various Posts, then click on the apply online link given below. You can apply online. Remember the last date to apply for this job is 4th January, 2024
What is your passion? Are you fascinated by art, biology, business, technology? Combine your passion with a desire to help others and become a librarian!
Librarians work in various settings, including public libraries, colleges, universities, schools, museums, hospitals, and businesses. They research, instruct, and connect people to technology. They also build websites, digitize archives, and manage social media. Librarians work with people of all ages, connecting them to information, learning, and the community.
These days a librarian does a lot more than check out materials and shelve books. Technology expert, information detective, literacy expert, trainer, and community programming coordinator are just a few of the hats a public librarian wears.
As a collaborator, change agent, and leader, the school librarian develops, promotes and implements a program that will help prepare students to be effective users of ideas and information, a lifelong skill.
Academic librarianship is for those who are constantly intellectually curious and who can apply that curiosity to efforts that help increase the knowledge base of the institution for research, teaching, and learning.
Special libraries offer unique opportunities to work in places such as corporations, hospitals, the military, museums, law firms, advertising agencies, professional associations, private businesses, and the government.
Librarians' and library workers' salaries vary according to the individual's qualifications and the type, size, and location of the library. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median annual wage of librarians in 2023 was $64,370 per year. The Bureau of Labor Statistics has also reported that librarian employment is expected to grow by 3 percent between 2022 and 2032. (This is as fast as the average growth rate for all occupations.)
Visit Occupational Employment Statistics for librarians' latest national, state, and local earnings data.
Occupational Outlook Handbook for Librarians at the Bureau of Labor Statistics has more detailed information about educational requirements, work environment and job outlook for librarians and library workers.
For additional information and resources on salaries for library employees, visit the American Library Association-Allied Professional Association (ALA-APA) .
Requirements. A master's degree in library science (MLS), preferably from an American Library Association (ALA) accredited program, is necessary for most librarian positions in most public , academic , and special libraries. School librarians may not need an MLS but must meet state teaching requirements.
Choosing an ALA-Accredited Program. Find additional information about how to select a library science program and more resources here: How to Choose a Library Science Program.
By Priscilla K Shontz & Richard A Murray. Presents descriptions of job responsibilities, education and training, and a typical workday for different types of librarians working in public, academic, school, and special libraries, as well as in jobs . . .
By Rachel Singer Gordon
By G. Kim Dority. "This is a book you will turn to again and again throughout your career. With numerous tables, worksheets, lists, and extensive bibliographies . . . it gives you everything you need to begin this journey." --Jacket
San José State University School of Library & Information Science has prepared a report entitled “MLIS Skills at Work.” It is an annual snapshot analysis of the latest career trends for information professionals. This report explores the career opportunities for individuals who hold a Master of Library and Information Science (MLIS) degree. The report indicates that in addition to the title of Librarian, the following list of representative job titles is indicative of the diverse ways library information knowledge is being applied in various professional areas:
Read interviews conducted by Caitlin Williams, Ph.D. with library workers in various specialty areas of the library profession.
Share This Page
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
The Guidelines for Recruiting Academic Librarians have been developed to serve as an outline of the prototypical recruitment process . Within academic and research libraries, recruitment for a librarian position may follow different processes depending on the employment category used for librarians or other factors at that particular institution.
Chang conducted research to compare the percentage of academic librarians of certain ethnicities to the percentage of students from the same ethnicity in each region of the United States. 15 Research findings indicate that within Academic Research Libraries (ARL) located in New England, the Mid-Atlantic, East North Central, West North Central ...
For additional information on training, or to get a representative to attend a local career fair, contact the ALA Office for Human Resource Development and Recruitment (HRDR) at 1-800-545-2433 ext. 4277, [email protected]. Compilation of recruitment resources and activities to the library profession.
The Recruitment, Retention, and Advancement of Librarians of Color -Page 1 of 37 Achieving Racial and Ethnic Diversity among Academic and Research Librarians: The Recruitment, Retention, and ...
An academic librarian is responsible for managing and curating the information resources within an academic or research library associated with an educational institution, such as a university or college. These librarians support the teaching, learning, and research missions of the institution by providing access to a diverse array of scholarly materials.
Career Video on becoming a Librarian from CareerOneStop. (Scroll down to "L' to find Librarian) If you would like to discuss the possibilities of careers in the library profession, you may contact HRDR staff, Beatrice Calvin at 800/545-2433 ext. 4280 or [email protected]. Email.
At the Association of College & Research Libraries Conference in 2019, Cunningham, Guss, and Stout presented the findings of their research, which focused on survey results of library directors who were asked about recruiting for diversity, and they specifically asked library directors to address the concept of fit. 6 The respondents used terms ...
Turkey: 10.3%. India: 2.6% Taiwan: 1.3%LIBRARIANS AND PROMOTING RESEARCHThe librarian's role is constantly changing and expanding - this is a. rofession which has proven its adaptability over centuries. While continuing their traditional role of curating and providing access to information, librarians are now acti.
Recruiting services. LibGig is your go-to resource for librarians, researchers and other knowledge and information management workers. It's our specialty. As part of the LAC Group family, LibGig brings valuable insights and best practices to information center staffing and services.
Tarida received her MS in library and information science from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Her research interests include diversity, equity, and inclusion, early career development and mentoring, and outreach programming. Tarida was an ALA Emerging Leader and is an alumna of the Minnesota Institute for Early Career Librarians.
Arizona. High school diploma/GED + 2000 hours of paid or unpaid library work + 162 contact hours of documented training in specified Core Competencies (Foundations, Administration, Services, Collections, Technology) completed within 5 years. Renewal: 45 additional contact hours every 3 years in any Core Competencies.
A master's degree in library science or information studies is necessary for most librarian jobs. How to Become a Librarian. An inquisitive mindset is a beneficial character trait for a future ...
2. Complete a bachelor's degree. Once you decide on a specialty, start completing a bachelor's degree. Since most librarians need master's degrees, having a bachelor's degree first can help you prepare for graduate school and increase your chances of securing admission to a great program. Aspiring librarians can choose almost any major, but it ...
Raman Research Institute Recruitment 2024 | Librarian Job Vacancy | Bangalore Job Vacancy | #jobRecommended Channels: @BangaloreJob @RamanResearchInstitute @...
Aug 08,2024 - Directions for Questions: Study the following information carefully and answer the quEstions which follow: A Research Institute is recruiting a librarian to digitise its information resources among other duties. Candidates must possess the following criteria. The candidate must -(i) be not less than 35 years and not exceed 40 years as on 01 .11 .2009.
• I value the contribution we as librarians and staff make to teaching, learning and research on our individual campuses as well as to the global community of scholars. ~Jennifer Younger You might be an academic or research librarian if you . . . 50 E. Huron St., Chicago, IL 60611 (800) 545-2433 ext. 2523 • Fax (312) 280-2520
CMT. The Chartered Market Technician® (CMT) credential is the preeminent, global designation for practitioners of technical analysis. Awarded to those who demonstrate mastery of a core body of knowledge of investment risk in portfolio management settings:
Directions for Questions: Study the following information carefully and answer the quEstions which follow: A Research Institute is recruiting a librarian to digitise its information resources among other duties. Candidates must possess the following criteria. The candidate must -(i) be not less than 35 years and not exceed 40 years as on 01 .11 ...
Raman Research Institute, Bengaluru. Advt - 2/2023 - dtd 04/11/2023. 1. Graduate in Science. 2. Postgraduate qualification in Library and Information Science. The qualification should have been achieved as a regular course. 3. 10 years' experience in a library at a reputed research/academic institute. Method of Selection: Personal Interview.
Cancer, an international interdisciplinary journal of the American Cancer Society, publishes high-impact, peer-reviewed original articles and solicited content on the latest clinical research findings.Spanning the breadth of oncology disciplines, Cancer delivers something for everyone involved in cancer research, risk reduction, treatment, and patient care.
Knowledge of the philosophy and techniques of library service. Ability to organize job duties and work independently. Demonstrated knowledge of library materials and resources. Creativity to develop and implement library programs and services. Ability to communicate both orally and in writing. Positive attitude toward library users with special ...
The article first describes the issue and current state of U.S. alternative traffic enforcement strategies, highlighting challenges in measuring disparities. It then provides a summary of documented alternative traffic enforcement reforms, initiatives, and related research. The article closes with a description of future research opportunities.
Home » WII invites applications from INDIAN NATIONALS for 08 contractual positions of research/project personnel under various research projects. (WII/ADVT. 3/RP-CELL/August, 2024) ... Researchers Recruitment and Placement Cell (RRP Cell) Captive Breeding and Zoo Management; ... This is the official website of Wildlife Institute of India ...
Librarian: Pay Level (As per 7th CPC) Level-13: Vacancy: 01: Essential Qualifications: Graduate in Science. Postgraduate qualification in Library and Information Science. The qualification should have been achieved as a regular course. 10 years' experience in a library at a reputed research/academic institute. For Deputation
Librarian and Various Posts. Job Location: Sadashivanagar, Bangalore, 560080 Karnataka. Last Date: 4th January 2024. Employment Type: Full-time. Number of Vacancy: 03 Posts. Educational Qualification: Candidates Should have Master's Degree, Bachelor's Degree from a recognized University.
There are a wide variety of specializations in library jobs which can vary depending on the type and size of the library. Usually, larger libraries offer more specialized positions. In addition, special libraries (i.e. law libraries, music libraries, etc.) require very specific subject knowledge and skills in addition to professional library knowledge and skills.
However, the detailed mechanism of retromer recruitment to the vacuole membrane has not yet been elucidated. Here, we show that the vacuolar SNARE complex MoPep12-MoVti1-MoVam7-MoYkt6 regulates retromer-mediated vesicle trafficking by recruiting the retromer to the vacuole membrane, which promotes host invasion in Magnaporthe oryzae.
A master's degree in library science (MLS), preferably from an American Library Association (ALA) accredited program, is necessary for most librarian positions in most public, academic, and special libraries. School librarians may not need an MLS but must meet state teaching requirements. Choosing an ALA-Accredited Program.